Blog
Ambiguous Content
Posted on 11/25/2015
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I enjoy thinking about and writing about art. To say that this is one of my favorite pleasures is not far off the mark. Writing helps to clarify my thinking. I get to see where I may be uncertain or may have question, and sometimes I can find ambiguities, which to me are good things to note for I have more possibilities how to understand something. Many are probably familiar with various so-called Gestalt images, ones that can be seen as different but coincidental shapes like the faces-vase drawings, or the young woman with a feather hat and the old crone, or the line drawing cubes that can appear to open from several different sides. All it takes is a slight adjustment of one’s focus to see the image one way or the other. The images are ambiguous – they have built-in possibility to be read as young woman or old crone, and so on with the others.
There are many words in language (this applies not only to English) that can have multiple meanings and multiple usages. These words we usually understand in context of what is being said and often do not have to consciously think about an alternative meaning. We know from experience what is meant. At other times, however, we might be caught off guard and misinterpret, or maybe the word order is such that alternate meanings are unintentionally applied. Or, if there is no clear context, we may have difficulty understanding. For example, consider the statement, everybody saw her duck. Did we see her move to physically avoid something? Did we see the duck that belongs to her? Without the context, we don’t know what is intended. We could use many examples, but this one makes the point.
How does this relate to art other than some double image as mentioned earlier? We might think that paintings of observed reality are without ambiguity if they are accurately observed and accurately portrayed. This may apply to some realistic paintings especially those of an illustrative nature. Many artists, however, may emphasize certain parts while de-emphasizing or even obscuring other parts. This doesn’t make them less realistic, but we might call the paintings interpretive depending on what the artist intends to show.
Consider many Dutch Golden Age still life paintings, particularly those that represent an elaborate table setting with an overturned glass of wine, slightly disturbed tablecloth, or partially peeled piece of fruit. Everything is acutely observed and rendered with care, but we don’t know about the suggested disturbance. Has someone abruptly left because of an emergency? Have lovers exited the dinner in lustful haste? The setting seems ordinary enough, but the story behind it is ambiguous, and we as observers are left to guess once we have admired the skill of the artist in representing the many objects portrayed.
More often than not, art gives us far more than what is first seen, and it is these second or third interpretations that lead us into the deeper mysteries that may be hidden within the work even as we uncover secrets within ourselves. Art draws us out as it draws us in, and we often are enriched by the ambiguity that allows us to exercise our own interpretive muscles.
Leave a Comment