Blog
Artistic Inventions
Posted on 5/3/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | The Working Artist | Thoughts on Art

History painting is narrative in pictorial form, but the narrative is frozen unless the image is segmented into scenes or chapters, and then it is episodic. The canvas is like a proscenium upon which the narrative plays out. It is the Renaissance idea of the canvas as a window on the world enlarged to the scale of epic drama. Mid-twentieth century painters maintained the scale but largely eliminated the narrative so that the picture space represented only color or color and shape or color and shape and texture. Narrative became non-existent within the painting. Even painters who still used recognizable images did so in fragments. Juxtaposition of images was the same as putting together different kinds of shapes that made a collection (collage) of image fragments. The image might have symbolic value or meaning, but there was no narrative intended. The only story might be that behind the making of the painting but not something depicted in the painting as in times past.
A painting, of course, can be many things, can basically be whatever the painter chooses for it to be. The question might arise, however, what the painter’s purpose is in making the painting. Is the same asked of the writer or the poet? Is a writer not telling a story in short or long form? The writer generally doesn’t write just to be writing. One could do that, but the outcome might not be very readable. It likely would have no sensible form. It might only contain sense impressions or fluid language, perhaps with some rhythm, images that might not connect, or sentences that might not express complete thoughts. We expect for there to be sensible content in writing for these are thoughts committed to paper for the purpose of communicating ideas and concepts.
On the other hand, we don’t usually ask the meaning of music. We expect music to be melodic, to have some structure that makes it worth listening to, but it doesn’t have to make sense in the way that writing does. There are forms of music that have text, that tell a story, but the story could be removed and the musical sounds would still be pleasurable and meaningful in a different way. From these comparisons it should be clear that each art form has its special way of communicating, and there also are special ways in which each is created.
Considering painting again, one could take a very lofty road and say that painting is strictly visual. It has nothing to do with narrative although it could be used to present a kind of narrative. Any representation of recognizable things is primarily about color or light and usually the combination of both. It is the manipulation of color that creates the effects of light, and through the effects of light, we can see recognizable things. This kind of painting is like music that has a program around which it is built and which it is attempting to portray: the sense of being in nature, for example, or the bustle and energy of a modern city, or the dramatic emotional swings of an operatic tale.
Symphonic music is more like what is called abstract, non-objective, or non-representational painting. There can be sense impressions, but these are vague and ambiguous. Something might feel warm or cool, but there is no real world thing to connect that warmth or coolness to as there would be in representations of a desert scene or a snow scene. We might simply see something that is predominantly red or predominantly blue. The ultimate experience of painting, however, regardless of imagery, technique, or even artistic intention, is seeing first followed by feeling. Whatever else is experienced comes mainly from the viewer. It is brought to the painting and brought out by the painting, but it is the viewer’s response and not that of the artist.
Leave a Comment