Blog
Questions and Answers, or Not
Posted on 11/23/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

A student said recently in a paper written about swimming that people first learned how to swim in the Stone Age. That struck me as a curious fact, and when I asked her how she knew that she said that people must have known. How else could they have gotten across lakes and seas? I then questioned how she knew that Stone Age people had traveled across lakes and seas. Events in prehistory are conjecture for the most part. There is enough evidence to track some movement of people during those times based on fossils, bones, and artifacts, but no evidence of boats exist that far back. Migrations typically occurred along coasts where there was access to food and water. People had to be able to sustain themselves by hunting and foraging since there was no way to carry enough food (either in quantity or in ability to preserve food for enough time). Historical evidence of boats and ships only daters back several millennia, and likely there was some water transportation in the form of dugout canoes or log rafts, but there is no hard evidence of that until the time of the ancient civilizations. We can make all manner of assumptions, but wishing doesn’t make it true.
The cave paintings that date back tens of thousands of years show that those ancestors were observant, cooperative, and utilized hunting animals as one source of food. The marvelous images show an intelligent people, ones who could pass on their skill in representation. How far this spread, however, is impossible to say since the evidence is so isolated and actually remained hidden from subsequent developed civilizations for thousands of years. Unlike historic times when information and knowledge are preserved and passed along systematically generation to generation, these early people can only be assumed to have been somewhat similar to primitive cultures known in remote and insulated areas of the world. Perhaps this was the case, but to assume that swimming or any other endeavor or skill existed at a particular time is a far-reaching stretch of the imagination when there is no evidence to support that idea. Would someone have ventured out in waters on some kind of floating device without the ability to swim? How could we possibly know that? The explorer Thor Hyerdahl did prove that it is possible to sail across an ocean first on a raft and later in a reed boat, but he could never prove that ancient sailors actually did that.
Archaeology and art have helped us understand many things about the distant past and much more about the more recent past when the record is most substantial. Art helps us tremendously to understand our ancestors. Those very distant ones, though, will always remain mostly mysterious and will continue to be subjects of conjecture and inquisition.
Leave a Comment