Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Thoughts on Narrative

J.L. David - The Death of Socrates
J.L. David - The Death of Socrates

            I enjoy stories and have admired those who can tell a good story filled with detail, engagement, and drama although I later learned to enjoy character nuance and atmosphere over dramatic action. Story is best in literary from, which can also include oral stories. Sometimes, though, narrative can work well in paintings, but this is far more of a challenge for the visual artist than the literary one.

            Visual stories are snapshots or illustrations of a moment from a story. The context of the story and what happened prior to what is illustrated and what came after have to be implied rather than narrated. A visual illustration focuses on one aspect of the story and simply cannot create the narrative unless the format is a graphic novel or an extended mural illustrating successive moments of the developing plot. Also consider comic books or comic page serials that extend a narrative over many weeks. History paintings are rarely more than large scale illustrations that may blend several plot points and represent them simultaneously.

            Some painters have mastered suggestion and mystery in order to present narratives in paintings. Look at Vermeer’s paintings and see how easy it is to grasp a narrative from the calm, detailed interiors. The same could be said for Rembrandt’s religious illustrations or a painting like Velazquez’s Las Meninas. Goya’s The Third of May 1808 or many of Henry Ossawa Tanner’s biblical scenes are inventive narrative paintings that combine technical exploration with familiar narratives to make strong artistic statements. These works are interesting paintings and such powerful visual renderings that the narrative is of lesser importance unlike portraits where the sitter is of prime importance. The emotional impact of Picasso’s Guernica is less about narrating the event as presenting a combination of figures subjected to incredible violence within a matter of moments. There is no prolonged description of battle, the lead up to it or the aftermath from it – the focus is on momentary struggle, terror, and violence. Narrative is instantaneous rather than the traditional story arc found in written narratives.

            I would argue that the most successful narrative paintings have been those that focus on the emotional impact of the moment rather than the narrative as such since the latter cannot effectively be transmitted in a single picture. The painter looks for emotional and psychological images that create that impact and lets the narrative hover in the background like a supporting character. So, rather than being sequential as are written narratives, the visual narrative is a collection of symbols and metaphors. Characters may be posed at a heightened point of action (Goya’s aiming soldiers about to shoot their prisoners while dead prisoners lie beside them) or Vermeer’s mystery lady quietly reading a letter, but it is the emotional content that affects viewers the most. The before, during, and after of the narrative are compressed into a sense of visual tension created by light, color, and shape. Chronological time, the basis of any narrative, is suspended in favor of emotional impact.

 

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post