Blog
A Matter of Choice
Posted on 10/1/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Artistic Advice | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Within the United States this is a time of insidious political intrigue. Government officials are supposed to be representatives of the people, but in truth they serve their own political ambitions. Politics has become a money game, and those most adept at playing that game get to stay in office most of the time. With the country roughly divided between conservatives and liberals, we end up with a government that is barely functional at best and often, like now, not functional at all. The irony is that both sides claim democratic virtues, integrity, and claim to have the people’s interests at heart. In truth they only learn to frame issues so that the other side is blamed for dysfunction. They appeal to their base, but hopefully, one might wonder, the people will realize that both sides are simply gaming the system. As long as big money is at stake, neither side can be trusted to do the right thing. There is too much concern with power rather than substance.
Sometimes I worry about the art world as well. Much of what is fed to artists by way of advice has more to do with making money than with making good art. The artist, in effect, becomes a brush for hire, but this is what used to distinguish fine art from commercial art. The latter was in business to make money and the former to make art. There were assumptions embedded in both sides of the equation. On the commercial side, the artist was seen as a skilled artisan hired to do a specific job. The response might be creative only insofar as the product met the specifications of the client. On the fine art side, the artist created his or her own work from personal choice free of dictates from a boss, an overseer, or a demanding client. The artist called the shots.
Even within the realm of fine art, though, there has always been the carrot of making it big. For some artists, that might mean compromising a principle here or there. The gallery might say, this is what sells, so give us more of this. So, the artist might do more of that thing in order to make the sale. The absurdity of this was dramatized in Woody Allen’s film Hannah and Her Sisters. The artist lover of the younger sister is brought a rock star client by Hannah’s husband who is the musician’s accountant. His purpose is to impress the younger sister whom he lusts after. The artist is insulted by the musician’s insistence on “something really big” as opposed to something of particular quality. The artist erupts in anger and insists that he doesn’t sell work by the yard. He gets to play the part of the purist, and is a kind of stand-in for Allen who has skirted the edge of the Hollywood system by being his own writer, director, and producer.
Artists have always been supported in some manner whether by the state, the court, the church, or by patrons. Art has been a commodity of sorts for about the same length of time. The growth of a middle class may have democratized and commercialized art more than any other factor as the means for creating art became more widely available beyond the relative few that could attain the court positions or favor of the church. The more money that has come into the mix the more artistic integrity has been challenged. Some artists have been pulled into the mainstream and some have remained on the outskirts. Can we say today that the artist has more choice in this matter? Perhaps. Unless we think of ourselves as victims of circumstance, a pretty weak position in my opinion, the choice of direction is always there before us.
Leave a Comment