Blog
Like It or Not
Posted on 6/30/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

There was a time when artists struggled to create paintings that were true to life and gave the undeniable visual experience of the natural world. The development of linear and aerial perspective plus many technical developments during the Renaissance raised the art of painting to unprecedented levels, as far as we know never before seen by humans. Perhaps the ancient Greeks had achieved such levels of verisimilitude if we are to believe written records, but we have no visual records to verify the stories. These, of course, were times when photography and other mechanical means of reproduction were unknown. Painting was the ultimate form of visual expression.
As we look back at these early masters, we can see that they often took liberties within their singular styles. Some created images with more defined edges and outlines. Some worked with brighter colors, greater modulation in shading, heavier or thinner applications of paint, and other variations that might distinguish the style of one from another. A few exaggerated forms in unusual ways (El Greco, for example). The differences in stylistic approach also give evidence of a kind of abstraction or simplification or high selectivity on the part of these artists. This suggests an implicit understanding that a painting is always a painting and not the thing itself.
Modernism, or more specifically modernist painters, attempted to redefine what a painting actually is. This led some to deny anything resembling what we might see in the world around us. The painted image had to be only referential to itself – color, shapes, forms, linear elements that had nothing to do with anything observed. For them, painting had to be purified in that way, at least from their perspective. Some of these so-called abstractionists, however, couldn’t quite divorce themselves from symbolic thinking and gave titles to their works that evoked myths or legends or other references to the past or to something spiritual. At one level this was little different from painting a picture of something that would also serve as a symbol of some aspect of life. Even paintings that are made spontaneously and in the moment tend to pull from the artist’s emotions and feelings as well as intuitive thought, thereby becoming expressive of those things. Thus, there is a kind of abstract content that matches the abstract images.
Personally, I doubt that any interpretation or explication of a painting of any kind is going to limit the appreciation or understanding on the part of the viewer. We have the capacity to respond to many types of aesthetic experience, and none of us are required to like something just because someone else does or doesn’t. Classifications are for convenience as tools to assist our understanding, but classifications should not limit or qualify a work nor even be an indicator of its artistic value. We like what we like, and maybe we can learn to like what we may initially not like. Mostly that will depend on how flexible our thinking happens to be.
Leave a Comment