Blog
Posted on 12/30/2016 6:33:01 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

We perceive through our senses. This is our lot in this corporal form, and it is also one of our greatest blessings. We are receivers and to some extent transmitters of energy. We think and feel and do. Our senses attune us to our surroundings and to inner realms that are as mysterious as those territories physicists attempt to understand through experimentation, mathematics, and investigative conjecture. We may well be more than this body that we inhabit. We may, as some believe, have senses beyond the normal five that connect us to other realms only so far imperfectly perceived by some who claim to know the truth that only they can see. But, if only we would open our eyes, if only we would look inward to the real self within, if only we would get in touch with our true nature, then we would know. Language sometimes gets in the way, for we use it literally and symbolically within the same breath. Yet today, scientists, those purveyors of the real and true and verifiable, speak of the mind-body connection and of the body knowing just as the brain knows. Cells have memory. Cells communicate within and without in ways that belie chemistry only.
How simple it seems to combine several colored pigments on a surface and by their interaction create the appearance of an arm, a tree, or a flower. And yet, when these elements are combined with skill and understanding, we may also see emotion, intrigue, understanding, intelligence, or whatever else the painter may intend for us to see and experience. Is this not miraculous? Something happens within our mind-body as perceivers, something that connects with what we know or have experienced, and we are moved to a completely different realm of experience vis-à-vis the painting we observe. We know something beyond the flat, paint-encrusted cloth that hangs before us. Time and space and other sensations have little relevance as we hover before the visual Mesmer. We can travel a thousand miles or a thousand years within the space of an instant. We are transformed as we translate in that artistic moment just as our bodies do their internal transformative dances without us having to think about where the blood goes or when. Fortunately, we have awareness that enables us to perceive beyond the physical even as we experience through the physical.
Posted on 12/29/2016 6:51:06 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

An argument often made by abstract painters is that abstraction is pure expression. Whatever happens within the field of the canvas or whatever surface is being acted upon has nothing to do with anything external. There is only the action of the artist in the moment of conception. There is a direct line between whatever the artist feels and what is put down on canvas. The realist or observational artist is always tied to the subject. Changes may be made from what is observed to what is painted, but the painted image refers continuously to the observed subject. Is there a real distinction here between two approaches to painting or are there simply variations on the same idea; i.e. making a painting?
The abstractionist at some point in the process of making is going to be observing the painting and making adjustments, refinements, or whatever additional applications of paint are called. In short, the painter is responding to the developing image just as much as the observational painter is responding to the observed subject. The only real difference is that the realist painting has some resemblance to something in the outside world. The abstract painting resembles only itself or possibly some inner image that no one but the painter sees. Nonetheless that painting is a representation of something – an idea, a feeling, a meditative state – ultimately that matters no more than the realistic painting looking like a particular place, for if that is all that any viewer sees when looking at the finished product, the it doesn’t really matter that it is a painting at all. What matters is that it looks like something recognizable, and even the most devout realist is going to argue that the painting is much more.
However, when the viewer sees the painted image and recognizes it as such, then the art is being observed and appreciated. To judge a painting on its verisimilitude solely (or lack of it) is to seriously misjudge the intention, purpose, and performance of the artist. The act of painting is a kind of performance whereby the painter is inspired by something emotionally and intellectually and then uses paint to express that idea or feeling (or some combination of both) in the form of a physical object that embodies history, process, commentary, and sensibility as a unique visual phenomenon. The art object becomes the sole focus of attention and speculation. It may be linked to others of its kind, but ultimately that singular work is where both artist and viewer arrest their attention. Whether it reminds one of something else seen or felt or otherwise experienced is only a small part of the overall experience that occurs in its presence. What is seen always depends on the viewer.
Posted on 12/28/2016 1:19:46 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Sliding Window
My dad had a thirty-three year career as a commercial airline pilot. On rare occasions the weather might be bad enough for flights to be canceled, but what most of us would call bad weather, heavy rain or thunderstorms or possibly sleet or snow, was not always severe enough to warrant cancelations. There might be flight delays, and most seasoned travelers know about those, but nothing else. Anyone who has flown in bad weather, and for pilots this is very important, knows that there is a ceiling, the uppermost limit of storm clouds above which the air is clear and the sun is shining. Once above that ceiling, anyone can look down on a sea of white like a huge blanket of snow and understand that this beautiful view hides that foul weather far below. All the friends and family left behind in the rain or other bad weather still experience that while the traveler revels in the most magnificent views of cloudscapes brightened by uninterrupted sunlight. There is truth in the old cliché about the sun always shining somewhere.
In a large house or building the ceiling of a room is also the bottom of the floor in the room above it. It is a division of space clearly defining the separation and connection between two adjacent areas. Artists experience this all the time in drawing and painting. The edge of an object, its contour, is simply the separation between the space on the inside and that on the outside, or, as an artist might say it, the separation between the object and the not-object. This is also described as positive shape and negative space. These two ideas are conjoined, for that edge that separates them also connects them whether in a two-dimensional drawing or a three-dimensional sculpture even though we might tend to think of the sculpture like any object as a separate and self-contained entity.
Sculptors know, however, that an object activates the space that surrounds it. Architects understand this also and think constantly about how space is most effectively utilized as they design a structure. The artistic audience sees the object against a background in a painting, sees the physical sculpture in its environment, or occupies the space of a dwelling or other building for now he or she is contained within that space. In each case, the audience is affected by the perception of space, and to fully appreciate the work in question the audience must consider how the space is utilized within or in relation to that work. Imagine, for example, stepping into a Gothic cathedral whose ceiling soars to a hundred feet or more above. Modern hotels might have a central core even higher. The sensation is definitely uplifting.
Artists are concerned with perception and with creating perceptual experiences for the viewer. The illusion of space around a painted or drawn object depends on several observations. One can be recognition of whatever object is portrayed, so the recognizable shape might be the first consideration. That would mean outline and proportion are clearly discernable. The outline may be a line or it may be contrast between light and dark that gives the appearance of line (edge) and appropriate shape (to make the positive shape and negative space). Manipulation of light and shadow allow the artist to give a sense of weight and solidity to an object (or transparency in the case of a glass object). An interior painting of a cathedral could convey that soaring sensation just as a landscape can suggest nearly infinite receding distance. Appearance depends on the handling of materials by the artist. We may not see the sunlight through the virtual cathedral window, but the sensation is palpable nonetheless. Even abstract works can represent light or space or substance according to the will of the artist. The ceiling that is the work of art reveals rather than hides its weather patterns, again according to the will of the artist.
Posted on 12/27/2016 6:12:23 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Impressionist Window
French landscape and figure painter universally admired by the Impressionists Camille Corot once said “I also think it isn’t so much the site as the interpretation that makes the work.” Corot was an early advocate of plein air painting, and because of his stature as a painter and colorist as well as being genuinely kind and helpful to younger painters, strongly influenced not only the Impressionists but also most landscape painting of the latter nineteenth century in France. There is some irony that Corot did not much like the work of the young Impressionists. He was very particular about color and value and was not partial to the broken color and sketchiness favored by many of the younger painters. Even so, he emphasized the importance of the first impression when working from nature. Coming as we do so much after the fact, we find much baggage surrounding the use of the word impression and tend to overlook that many painters were concerned about capturing impressions of their subject so that their paintings would remain fresh and vibrant even when completed in the studio.
In short, the Impressionists were not the only painters concerned with impressions, and to see them too narrowly according to that characterization is to slight them and others working around the same time but not as part of that particular group. The Impressionists, after all, are a very diverse group of painters who shared some ideas but also explored personal agendas as individual artists. The range of Pissarro’s work is impressive in its own right regardless of his association with the Impressionists. The same could be said of Monet or Renoir and others.
Posted on 12/25/2016 6:25:22 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Crisscross
Sensation can mean that something or someone is a great hit, very popular, or exceedingly successful. Sensation can also be a feeling, the barest notice of something tactile or otherwise perceived by the senses like a faint hint of light in a darkened space. We are sensational beings in that we are quite remarkable in many ways, but also we experience our aliveness and connection to the world through our senses. In philosophy and literature there is long-standing conflict (as it is phrased) between logic represented by the reasoning brain and emotion represented often by sex, arguably the strongest of the emotional urges. This conflict gives rise to art and to religion both of which are largely emotion based responses to the world.
Art depends on sensation in order to be experienced. There is the physical response in the art being seen of felt or heard, and the emotional response on the part of the viewer in the presence of the work. Additionally, the viewer (audience) may respond intellectually with reason and logic that may make comparisons, associations, ask questions, analyze and otherwise evaluate by applying critical judgment. At the physical level, mind (intellect) and body (sensation) work together to enhance experience not only of art but also any kind of aesthetic or natural experience. As human beings this is what we do.
The sensitive, caring, and thoughtful individual will develop both reasoning and emotional skills in order to more fully engage with the world. Many psychologists now suggest that there are forms of intelligence beyond the traditional view of intelligence being measured by the use of language and logic. Differing theories will categorize intelligence into seven, nine, or ten areas that describe a person’s ability to adapt to various situations and experiences with ease or difficulty depending on that person’s intelligence make-up. It is also possible to improve one’s intelligence in areas that may be lacking or less well developed. Participating in art either by creative action or by active appreciation can exercise one’s spatial, emotional, kinesthetic, intuitional, linguistic, logical-mathematical, or musical intelligences contingent on how one interacts with the aesthetic experience but regular exposure will surely generate positive results.
Posted on 12/23/2016 5:10:32 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

What unfolds over a lifetime is never predictable unless one takes the cradle to grave philosophy verbatim and cynically projects the simplest scenario: birth and death. There are countless variants explaining what falls in between. Some carefully plan their lives and hopefully move forward on the chosen path adhering as best they can to the formulated plan. But, as the old cliché goes, “the best laid plans…” As humans, though, this is what most of us do, to make our plan for fitting in somewhere into the social structure in order to build a life.
In my lifetime, I’ve seen many variations among those I know personally and also have knowledge of generally. Some have been successful and others less so. Most life paths have veered this way and that, and the unexpected has often been more powerful than the expected. Many could agree that how those unexpected challenges are met shows character within the individual or lack thereof in some cases. This is our lot – we do or we don’t do according to choice and circumstance. The possibilities are many even when one subscribes to the pessimistic belief that it won’t matter ultimately what choices are made.
Obviously life and individual lives are far more complex than this simplistic view of birth and death. We want some semblance of order and perhaps some predictability and choose to apply these whenever we can. Perhaps this is a large part of the appeal of art and artistic expression, for although art may arise from challenge or conflict or inspiration, it generally allows us to strive for and to express a sense of order and resolution, attributes that life does not always provide. Art we can shape and mold and create clear lessons for ourselves and for others. There is a clear beginning, middle, and end, and the arc of the artistic narrative provides pleasure, enhancement, and intrigue while also creating a complete experience that may be accessed again and again while also being viewed from different perspectives. When we choose to learn from it, there is much it has to offer. A significant challenge is to live one's life as a form of art.
Posted on 12/22/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Intersection
The English writer and humorist Jerome K. Jerome wrote “It is always the best policy to speak the truth, unless of course you are an exceptionally good liar” (The Idler, 1892). It has also been said in different forms by many people that artists are in the business of telling lies for a living. Many artists would say that they speak the truth in their work or that they explore truth, investigate truth, search for truth, or create truth. Rarely, however, does one claim to have found the absolute truth, for most likely that would be an elaborate lie.
Truthfulness in art is as elusive as the definition of art itself. Writers create fiction in order to address the ineluctable truths of existence, those “verities of the heart” according to William Faulkner. They spin believable yarns about believable people who exist in believable alternate universes from those that we inhabit. Other artists in visual or performing arts express through their art the truth of their personal visions. We as audience take them at their word, so to speak, and judge them accordingly, for how can we truly know whether they are being true to themselves?
Any artistic expression is a kind of argument: the artist is making a claim using a particular medium, the art itself being the sole evidence to support that claim and sway the argument. Again, the audience finds the work credible or not. Do we come to art in the same way that we experience life or do we shift to some alternate way of understanding following certain expected guidelines part of which may be the suspension of disbelief as one might do with theater or film? Is art ever really simple and straightforward? Is it as easy as accepting that this is reality and this is not? Of course we may find aspects of the real world so bizarre that it is challenging to accept (sickness, war, death, inhumanity, variant belief systems, the election of ridiculous figures, global warming, and on and on).
Art may be a means of expressing truth, and if it is, it is expressing a truth or set of truths of one artist about his or her experience relative to concerns of the moment that the art is made. Painters do this with their paintings, poets with their poetry, and other artists with whatever medium they have chosen. Perhaps, then, we can say that artistic truth is existential and works best in the particular rather than as general observations that are always the same. If the latter were the case, an artist might only make a single work since everything else would simply be redundant.
So, artists are either exceptionally good (highly skilled at deception) at telling truthful lies or they have found numerous ways to tell the truth in different forms, the latter suggesting that truth has many manifestations, many colors, shapes, and forms.
Posted on 12/21/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Mystic Shades
There is a curious debate that has been going on in art for some time between artists who practice realism and those who practice abstraction. It may be thought that realistic portrayal of things in the world is the older of the two approaches to picture making, but I’m not so sure. Evidence of those magnificent cave paintings that date back forty to fifty thousand years are very realistic portrayals of animals, to be sure, although sometimes simplified but still very animated and lifelike. The best examples are in the twenty to forty thousand year range, and question remains whether there may be more undiscovered examples that could be much older. These likely didn’t develop full blown from some prehistoric artist’s imagination; there would have been development of forms and ways of rendering over time. Wouldn’t there? At least that’s what we are used to seeing within the range of recorded history. Pictorial representations have dominated historical art forms since the most ancient of civilizations, and Western art is built on the Ancient and Classical worlds.
However, those ancient shells found in Indonesia that have carved zigzag patterns on them are half a million years old (“Zigzags on a Shell from Java Are the Oldest Human Engravings,” Smithsonian, December 2014). This is a very strong argument that at least some hominids made abstract designs several hundred thousand years before any realistic images showed up in paintings or sculpture. Obviously, what prehistoric ancestors did as designs or some kind of decorative imagery are far removed from historical concepts of art of civilized ancient times and more so removed from concepts of the past five hundred years where artistic expression became a form of high art rather than simply decorative art. This evidence might persuade some that abstract design is older than realistic design, but does it really matter?
The question upon which the argument for one side or the other is based has to do with which has greater legitimacy (or truth) as art. Is this really an important question to ask? If we think about how a visual artist learns and uses the traditional apprenticeship model, we would see that young artists in training copied from the master’s work or made detailed drawings of studio objects in chalk or charcoal – not in color and not using paints. Even today artists do variations on this idea in drawing classes all over the world. So, aren’t these students already abstracting what they see if they are only working in black and white? Students are taught to see large masses, simplified forms, simple contrast between light and dark, and to focus on shapes rather than objects. Get the formal relationships right among contrasts, textures, shapes, and position, and the ‘object’ will emerge from that set of relationships. This is abstraction at its core. Students learn to draw realistically by training themselves to see abstract forms.
Abstract artists will say some variation of the idea that all art is abstract anyway. It is a semblance of something and not the thing itself. Even an abstract painting is composed of arranged materials that – it could be argued – have little to do with the resulting painting other than being component parts. The integrated whole of the work whether realistic or abstract is what comprises the art and not the ingredients, subject matter, or how those parts were manipulated. Criticism has taught us to abstract in reverse by deconstructing an art work whether visual, literary, performance, or otherwise. We take it apart to see how it works, or so we think, and then piece together ideas about its validity, veracity, or value. That can be theoretically interesting, but it does not get to the experience of the work: how someone feels when confronting a piece of art in the first place.
Posted on 12/20/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Saloon Doors
Humans love to name things, so much so that if something does not have a name, it can hardly be considered to exist because we would not recognize it. There would be nothing to compare it to. Think of the Great Mystery, that which has no name. To name that Mystery would be to contain it, to limit it, when in fact it is limitless. But see, we have a name for that, in fact, several names – limitless, infinite, eternal, everlasting, omnipotent, universal, and so on. All of these are things which are beyond our direct experience. We have some understanding of what it means to be limitless or all powerful or eternal, but we can only approximate what that means in our understanding.
In spite of this seeming limitation, we also understand many things that are not physical or concrete, things that we cannot see but can experience in some way. These abstract ideas we generally give names to because by doing so we can distinguish one from another. We can recognize them and discuss them and learn more about them. When we talk about something, we use language, a system of sounds derived from symbols called words in turn derived from letters and these associated with particular sounds and the words they make with particular meanings. We have become quite skilled at this practice, and it has become one of our primary ways of learning and communicating.
We also use other means to express our ideas, some of which, like art, are not direct in their description or explication. Often we use symbol and metaphor to communicate these concepts because figurative language allows us to be flexible, multi-layered, and expansive rather than particular as we might wish to be when describing something specific. In truth, our world has many mysterious aspects that our desire to know exactly is frustrated by. So we turn to art or philosophy or religion to find answers for the ineffable. We find that there are other ways of knowing besides reason and logic useful as these may be and have been. Right alongside these, though, we have used imagination, faith, and curiosity to explore inwardly as well as outwardly. Art has encompassed everything from the logical to the intuited, from the physical to the spiritual and all manner of steps in between. All have been given names, and those names led to other names and so on down through history.
Posted on 12/19/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The ability to take an idea or a feeling or just the sense of something and make that into an expressive statement is both a blessing and an awesome responsibility. There is a lot of press out there about being creative, about being uniquely you through a creative act, and about owning your power through creative expression. So much of this becomes clichéd and grants the smallest example as a magnificent accomplishment to be celebrated along with the masters. Okay, maybe that’s hyperbole, but baby steps that begin one’s journey down a creative path are just that: baby steps.
Accomplished artists work long and hard to improve and refine what they do. Some may start out more gifted than others, but even the gifted have to mature to be able to express powerfully. Being good at drawing, capturing a likeness, or making objects appear life-like are important skills (especially for a painter) but not a guarantee that any person will become an excellent artist. There is something else necessary. Call it the x-factor, personal vision, or a unique perspective. An element of understanding, a certain amount of knowledge, a sense of empathy, or sensitivity to some aspect of the world that others do not see – do not see, that is, until the artist shows them how and where to look – these are what separate an artist from the amateur.
In these days of political correctness, it becomes offensive to criticize someone’s efforts at creative expression. Without some direction, though, a person who wants to learn can get stuck in a feel-good mode with little incentive for improvement if that person is only given praise. When directed by an experienced teacher or mentor, the aspiring expressive can learn how to become better using the tools necessary, how to communicate more effectively, and how to hone that personal uniqueness that will lift his or her work to heights of achievement that otherwise he/she would not grasp, or might take far longer to attain.
Discouragement is only one of the roadblocks. The astute apprentice will know when a plateau has been reached in development. That person has come far, has learned much about self-evaluation and self-critique, so much so that he knows there is more but just can’t quite see how to get there. A well placed word from a teacher can help or, perhaps, through perseverance and doggedness the next level is reached without outside help. Something has to keep the individual moving forward, and this can be an internal or external motivator. This will likely depend on how that persona has been prepared to that point in time.
In short, there are no formulas for excelling at creative expression. The bottom line will always be in the doing since without the doing there is no expression in the first place.
Posted on 12/18/2016 6:27:00 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Window Box
Art is one of those concepts that is difficult to define. Not everyone has an opinion about it, but many people do, artists and non-artists alike. Most might agree that art is some sort of creative work, an expressive act that may or may not result in some tangible object that is the manifestation of the creative energy. Most might also agree that art has no real purpose other than to be itself. It might be beautiful or not; it might make commentary about society, culture, or political regime – or not. It may be representational meaning that it resembles something, for example, a painted portrait or a figurative statue or a landscape or objects as in a still life. Skill may be evident in the making of the work, and that may be its strongest attribute, or there may be the obvious lack of skill in the work as in much so-called modern art, the emphasis being on whatever ideas are expressed in the work (ready-mades, found pieces, recycled works, or works made from scraps).
Serious art is rarely anonymous – the work is almost always tied to a specific artist or group of artists. Some art may gain importance by its authorship. Sometimes it is nearly impossible to separate the art from the artist, and in today’s marketplace the artist promotes him or herself as a brand which in turn promotes the art. Attribution is of primary importance in the realm of art history. Consequently, art is usually qualified by artist, period, place of origin, school or stylistic expression, many of the things that casual viewers will likely know less about. Museums will aid their audience by supplying identifying placards, contextual statements, lectures, docent tours, films, and other supplemental information. Typically they are teaching institutions as well as repositories.
Even as one builds a contextual and historical knowledge base, it becomes apparent that the definition of art must be expansive, inclusive, and flexible. This should not be surprising since we’re considering all the creative expression of humanity at large for as far back as we can find examples. People being people, however, there will always be biases and preferences. The educated art appreciator will be more tolerant of dislikes and certainly more intelligent when building a case for or against particular art, artists, styles, media, or whatever he or she feels the need to defend or critique. In fact, because of the diversity and complexity in artistic expression, it becomes important for the audience to be educated. To be otherwise is to discount a major portion of humanity’s contribution to the planet.
Posted on 12/15/2016 8:02:11 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Consider the word, word. It is made up of four letters of the English alphabet, and it is a one-syllable word – a word spoke basically as one sound. It could be argued that pronouncing it creates more than a single sound. There is the wuh sound at the beginning, the er-sound of the letters or, and the duh sound of the d at the end. So the pronunciation is actually wuh-er-duh, but spoken quickly the sound is that of a single syllable.
Word is also the name of those things made from letters that signify a concept or idea, name something, or do some other English grammatical function as one of the parts of speech. Words make up the basic unit of a language that communicates an idea. Any word, of course, is an abstraction that looks nothing like the thing that it names or the concept that it communicates. Once we learn letters and words and their meanings, we assume their normalcy and tend not to think of them as abstractions for we readily understand their meaning. We associate all that we know of a thing with the word that names or describes it.
Such is the way of language. If we consider visual art, painting in particular, we now are faced with images: colors, shapes, forms, illumination, the illusion of space, texture, and many other characteristics of visual imagery. We can sometimes describe some of those elements or effects with words, but words do not give the same impression nor do they elicit the same kinds of complex emotional responses that images do. Often, when we might say that we understand a painting, we mean that we can explain it, explicate it like we might a poem or other piece of literature. Those art forms are made from words, so it seems natural to discuss and describe them with words including whatever emotional experiences we may have as a result of reading the works.
A painting, though, is different, and the experience of it is quite different. Words are linear and follow the logic of grammar and syntax. Paintings are not linear; they are multi-directional. They can be taken in all at once, or they can be perused at leisure over time. There is no particular order to the ‘reading’ of a painting though sometimes painters use directional clues to move the viewer’s eyes throughout a composition. That may be part of the painting’s design, but it is only part of it. The viewer chooses how to look; indeed, different viewers may experience paintings in unique ways. Painters are usually after something, an ineffable and enigmatic thing, that can only be sensed when it is found. It often cannot be explained in words, for if it could be, the painter might just as well have written it instead of having painted it.
The artist chose paint, for that mystery could only be presented in the form of a painting. Words would not create that experience or re-create it for the viewer. The visual field is the arena, and the painter approaches that with all the power and energy he or she can muster in order to convey the mystery for the viewer to unravel however it may be done. Seeing, feeling, and visual thinking are the tools of the audience, for it is with those same tools that the creator crafted the original work.
Posted on 12/14/2016 4:19:37 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A painter approaches a canvas as a screen upon which he or she will project a dynamic image that comes to life stroke after stroke, color after color, and shape upon shape. Layers are put into place similar in a way to how a house might grow from foundation to framework to coverings to finishing touches. Each stage lays preparation for the next stage to follow. The end product is complete in its functionality, and many earlier stages are hidden beneath the surface sheen.
Paintings may vary in style, intention, or scope. Some may be deliberate and slow in their development for they are carefully planned and executed start to finish. The end product is foreseen from the outset. Most geometric abstraction is built in this manner with the utmost attention paid to details as the painting progresses. Other paintings may be spontaneous, their process of development more intuitive rather than predetermined by design. We could almost say the painting has a voice in its development as the painter looks for feedback from the emerging image throughout the process. Paintings based on observation, on the other hand, are likely a combination of both processes: the painter has a concept clearly in mind from observing a scene or setting, but that setting remains a point of reference throughout the painting process. The painter also responds to what happens on the canvas for he is sensitive to the paint and the growing image.
Whatever version of the painterly process the painter follows, there is a kind of dialog that occurs between painter and painting, a give and take, if you will, where the actor and the acted upon are one and the same. At the end of the process, a completed work remains as evidence of the creative dance that occurred. That work in turn becomes a center of projection from the audience that encounters it. The painter is not there to explicate or to expound upon the visual experience that has now been handed over to the viewer. The painting lives, as it were, on its own, animates itself in the eyes of that audience.
We can say that a painting lives, a piece of art has a life of its own. We’re only partly being metaphorical since it is obvious the painting did not paint itself. However, it did not grow from nothing. There was a consciousness behind its coming into being, and much of that consciousness has now been given form as what we call art, a complex set of coded language that, in the case of painting, speaks without words and communicates without sound.
Posted on 12/13/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Window of Memory
Some years ago I participated in a drug study at Baylor College of Medicine’s Sleep Clinic. Doctors conducted a double-blind study on a particular medication as part of a larger study being created at several sleep centers around the U.S. The study lasted two weeks, and participants spent two five-day periods in the sleep lab where sleep was monitored by EEG and closed-circuit TV.
I remember the feeling of artificiality being wired to the EEG did not last long. It did not, as I initially thought it would, inhibit sleep at all. Perhaps it was because the room was completely soundproof and also completely dark. I could not see anything, not even my hand a few inches in front of my eyes. The only other experience I’ve had of such total darkness was in an isolation float tank, something I’ve done on several occasions.
Total absence of light, at least initially, heightens other senses. Perhaps over longer time span the other senses would become increasingly sharpened. Mine did not appreciably change, but my mind and imagination were free to wander without distraction. I had very rich and complex dreams while in the sleep clinic. My meditation in the float tank was at first very body aware. The high salt content of the water to enhance floatation could wreak havoc on scratches or scrapes of the skin. As the body acclimated to mild stinging and the salt water aroma, the mind became free to explore itself or its memories. Part of the purpose is for stress release, and I did experience that quite well. However, I also experienced vivid imaginings and visions of what seemed like living art works. Maybe I should call them virtual works since they were such that I could enter into them rather than simply see them.
In reality, a good painting takes the viewer to some virtual place that is partly grounded in the physicality of the work: its colors, shapes, spaces, and textures along with whatever images might be represented. These the viewer can contemplate at leisure through close observation. There also is the experience of seeing the work internally within the mind’s eye, so to speak. The viewer makes associations, interprets images, questions what he or she sees, and relates the images to other things he/she may know. The imagination of the viewer meets the captured imagination of the painter (as expressed in the painting). A new image emerges in the viewer’s mind that is a composite of all the minute observations that occur over seconds to however long the viewer actively observes, and these observations become memories, bits and pieces of visual information that construct the virtual painting within the viewer’s mind. It is equivalent to but separate from the physical painting, for the memory goes with the viewer for later access or to be used again either in private or should the viewer revisit the actual painting.
As a painter I carry images of paintings, my own and those of others, wherever I go. These are part of a continuum in the case of my work, a way of relating actively present work to what has come before – and I think this can be conscious or intuitive in the moment of creation. The mind remembers and connects the present with the past. I don’t see art as a spontaneous eruption of a feeling or idea spewed forth like Athena springing fully formed from the mind of Zeus. Art (painting), like life, is a process, and part of what makes any day wonderful is the context within which it is experienced. We may live in the moment and act in the moment, but our living and acting are part of the continuum that is the life that we lead. We are history in the making, and art is part of that history made manifest.
Posted on 12/12/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Offset
The instinct for survival is the most basic of our drives. We will fight for air if deprived of it or for water or food. We will do whatever is necessary to protect life. Even when unconscious, the body will do its best to preserve the life of the organism by withdrawing fluids from the extremities to protect vital organs. Our ancient ancestors struggled to find shelter and food, became hunters, and that physical response has remained within the psyche. It is not happenstance that hunting and other activities associated with being in nature are fundamental to so many humans. It is interesting also to see that making art goes back tens of thousands of years and even predates the development of writing. Humans made images long before they created the written word.
Today there is sometimes a rift between segments of society that are proponents of hunting, weaponry, especially guns, and various sports including conservative politics and those that favor aesthetics, literature, higher education, and progressive values. The former individuals are often classified as rednecks, fanatics, illiterates, fundamentalists, fascists, and are thought to be mostly intolerant. The latter are considered elitists, liberals, socialists, idealists, unrealistic, and generally fall left of center politically. The two are not mutually exclusive, however, for there are many shades of grey.
The connection between the hunter and the artist is an intriguing one. Some of the earliest images known depict hunters along with their prey. The impulse to make images may have been for magical purposes as some believe, giving hunters power over their prey. It might have been seen as a way to capture the spirit of an animal. That images might be considered magical or believed to have spiritual powers is still a viable idea within the art community. Art is seen by many as a connection between the corporal and the spiritual, the real and the imagined, sometimes a gateway to the soul or that ineffable human essence.
Art can also be a connector between those with opposing views such as the liberal and the conservative. Not all conservatives, for example, are aesthetically challenged nor are all liberals against hunting or other typically conservative issues. Art generally is not political although some art, satire for example, may be political on purpose, but that is a fairly small percentage of all art that is made. The educated person usually has some artistic interest, and there are educated people on both sides of the political spectrum no matter what the opposing side may say.
Art can tackle any subject from most any perspective. It is the artist who may express political or social views, not something that is inherent to art. Art can also be a powerful social tool, but more often than not it is a harmonizing and unifying force that reaches across political boundaries or other artificial barriers that are personally or culturally imposed.
Posted on 12/11/2016 6:36:46 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

We can say that art is a calling, an interesting term of whose origin I am unaware. I’ve heard it used most often to refer to a spiritual calling – someone hears or claims to hear the voice of God or God’s spokesperson in the form of an angel. So the calling and response to it is a metaphysical circumstance that some of a cynical bent might characterize as anthropomorphizing some aspect of the world. In any case, art may be a calling for some, and answering that call becomes a form of worship.
There are artists, though, that take a different view of the world, a negative and cynical one – not so much that the world itself is bad, for there is much beauty in it, but people are often corrupt and institute horrific practices that take advantage of others in order to seek their ow gain. Social ills result, suffering and tragedy ensue, and these artists hold themselves above and aloof from such. Art is their buffer, their fortress against what they see as debased and cruel. They are outsiders and often appear as the stereotypical misfit, intelligent, sensitive, eccentric, and disdainful of social mores. They tend to band together and create movements, manifestos, and other pronouncements concerning the sanctity of art and truth. Art is about truth and is truth; it cuts through all the elaborate lies the rich and powerful spin as they manipulate and maintain their hold on power.
There are other artists that simply want to create beautiful things. They are effectively apolitical but may join local museums, art groups, or supportive entities to strengthen ties with what they see as the art community. Art is a means of personal expression and from that a sense of personal satisfaction is gained.
This by no means covers the permutations among various artists insofar as personal commitment or personal viewpoint. Creativity functions on many levels, and being artistic is one level with many sub-levels of its own. Part of what makes art so interesting is the great variety among not only the work that is created but also among the artists who go about creating it.
Posted on 12/10/2016 6:29:51 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Art is impressive by any measure. At times in the distant past when science and medicine were in their infancy, long before germ theory and medicinal cures for common infections that today are rarely life-threatening, artists created incredibly sophisticated, highly crafted work that has stood as ideals of human expression for thousands and certainly hundreds of years. Even before there were known civilizations, humans created forms of art in stone and on cave walls that express intelligence, sensitivity, and manipulative skill. These existed when there was no agriculture, no written language, no viable transportation, and extremely limited means of communication.
The rise of civilization enabled humans to become more productive, more knowledgeable about themselves and others, increasingly inquisitive, and, ironically, more destructive as they became more constructive. The history of civilization is as much the history of conflict as it is the history of development. A ruler’s particular vision of uniting territories under one banner almost always involved conflict as the means to the end. Even religions succumbed to this mindset, and often they gave approval or legitimacy to what on one side would be seen as liberation while seen as terror on the side of those being ‘legitimized.’
Art chronicled many of these escapades and in some cases actively conspired. For many generations now, artists have been relatively free to pursue their own choices in what and when and why they create. Censorship still exists in some forms in some countries, even the freest ones, and there still are cases where artists are hired guns, so to speak. Whatever the circumstance, these questions remain to be answered: what is art, what is its purpose, and what is its value? The history of art gives us some clues, and there are references to truth and beauty, but these are open to interpretation. They are slippery and malleable, but, then, so is art. For something that is concrete when expressed, art still hovers in most any age somewhere just above the daily reality, for art is also metaphor and symbol. It creates a separate reality that is not bound by time or place. It exists in history and outside of it simultaneously. It outlives its creators yet echoes their experiences while creating new experiences for whatever current audience pays it mind.
Posted on 12/9/2016 4:52:42 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

People have become increasingly connected around the world. Ease of communication across distances has improved far beyond what existed several generations ago. Kids today, of course, have little sense of earlier times and likely think of complaints by parents and grandparents about short attention spans as just adults being adults. They’re not hip to what’s happening now.
Imagine, though, several thousand years past when horses and chariots were the only available transportation and most people, even armies, traveled on foot. It is remarkable that kings built great empires that might take an emissary years to cross. A lot can change in years. Who’s to say that a ruler would still be alive or in power by the time his message reached the furthest extent of the realm? Messages sent by bird could be lost. Messengers could be killed on purpose or by accident.
Considering the telegraph as a “modern” means of communication, we still find slow compared to radio, telephone or e-mail. Personally I have seen many changes in my lifetime, changes in technological tools that would have seemed magical to those ancients. I went through school, post-secondary and graduate schools years before computers and the internet were created. My primary learning tools were books, and libraries were the main source of those. Access to art and art images had been expanded greatly through visionary publishers who made visual history available to those who could not travel to the great museums or to ancient sites around the world. Slide film enabled us to see the great archaeological treasures in color and in settings that seemed real even if they were reproductions in a book or projected on a screen. We had to use imagination to picture the scale and proportion of these reproductions.
Today, of course, our access is even greater to these artistic treasures both past and present. Nearly instantaneous access to more than was available in the most fully stocked library is only a few clicks away. We can zoom in and out on many images, take virtual tours of the Sistine Chapel ceiling, prehistoric cave paintings, or most major museums. I carry that library on my hip and can dial in 24/7. This is indeed remarkable and still feels somewhat magical. By no means do I take any of this for granted.
I am also grateful, however, for that time without computers, for I learned how to learn, how to question, how to create context, how to interpret, and how to critically evaluate information. I see many young people and even some adults who cannot distinguish truth from fiction on the internet or in their e-mails. Also, in spite of all that information, many do not understand context historically, geographically, or socially, and this often creates a false perception of what information might mean. We still rely heavily on language to clarify thinking, express ideas, and interpret expression of others. Gaming skills or internet surfing skills will not substitute for basic communication skills.
Art has been and will continue to be impacted by all of this, and art of the future exists in a science fiction realm, for like science, we can only guess at what might happen in coming decades. Artists have been exploring new media since the turn of the last century (the twentieth, not the twenty-first). We have been through stages where painting has been declared dead numerous times, yet painters continue to paint and old traditions continue as well as evolve. It is exciting to experience all of this, and it is important to create understanding (context) that allows for growth without destroying the roots from which all has grown.
Posted on 12/8/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

There is a clichéd expression often heard with many different items in the fill in the blank section. “if you’ve seen one ______, you seen them all.” Some people say this about natural things: trees, flowers, birds, even other people. The idea is that there is nothing unique or different about each one. As Gertrude Stein said in another context, “Rose is a rose is a rose,” but she was being metaphorically ironic. My former father-in-law was a university professor, and a music professor friend of his once said that Vivaldi only wrote the same piece of music over and over – the academic variant of the above cliché. Granted Vivaldi’s most well-known work is The Four Seasons, but other works that may share stylistic characteristics are also different in character and scope. Glibness may be the hallmark of most clichés, but that doesn’t mean that we should only look at surface similarities and assume that nothing more interesting lies beyond.
How many times have I seen a bird in flight? I cannot say with accuracy, but I know it has been thousands. Still, a flight of birds or a single bird passing across an expanse of blue sky is cause for pausing and looking up. The flight of a duck is not the same as that of a seagull or a hawk or a sparrow. All these singular creatures and hordes of others are worthy of observance just as individual flowers can exert mystical hold upon one’s gaze, for there is majesty and mystery in the colors and shapes that any singular flower possesses.
We are the observers of the natural world. Unlike other sighted creatures that look and observe for safety or sustenance, we often observe for the pleasure of observing. We respond to beautiful sights, and we can see infinite varieties of beauty within all things that surround us in the natural world. To become so isolated that we do not comprehend or so insensitive that we overlook rather than see is a great waste of the power that has been given us as observers but more so as witnesses and chroniclers. Self-awareness, reason, and expressive ability uniquely qualify us to do what our species is designed to do, and that is to create. We put our powers and skills to work in order to fulfill our purpose, or one of our purposes, to recognize and acknowledge the beauty of which we are a part and in doing so to make new forms of beauty as we may experience it. This we share so that we may look again and again.
Posted on 12/7/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

While at work at my regular job – I teach and administer a library in a professional school – I often think about art. In fact, there is very little time of the day when I’m not thinking about art on some level. I could be shopping in a grocery store, driving on a freeway, walking in a park, or reading the newspaper of online news – some aspect of art will come to mind or be seen out in the world. Ideas and images are stored in memory for future use along with emotional responses to many situations, people, or observations. These are grist for the mill as one old saying goes.
Visual artists are trained to observe, to think about those observations, and to imagine by simply asking what if, a favorite core question for writers as well. Probably the majority of stories come from a write asking that simple question, what if – and from that could come something as complex and grandiose as War and Peace.
Artistic imagination knows no bounds. The surrounding everyday world may be the starting place, but through practice, discipline, and an ironic sense of free-wheeling visionary insight, artists will move into a creative space that can virtually build any world possible.
Art is the product of the human mind tempered by spirit. Intellect and emotion work in a kind of symbiotic relationship even when they might appear to be struggling with each other for dominance. Art is the result of this apparent conflict.
Posted on 12/6/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The other day I wrote about enjoyment of this time of year. I have so many memories connected with holidays and school and how both seemed to enrich the other. There was the desire to be away from school to enjoy the seasonal festivities and to just be a kid playing with other kids. But school also gave focus to the times, and we did all sorts of activities day by day that were celebratory and intermingled with learning. I particularly remember my Jewish friends who seemed to take all the Christmas energy in stride, but they shared sometimes about their traditions as well. Those were early introductions for me to ways of being other than my own. I began to see some of that otherness expressed in a wide range of art, and it was one of the things that drew me to art early on.
The different yule traditions throughout the world sometimes incorporate specific Christmas themes and sometimes not, but these are reminders of the richness of human experience. It saddens me when at such a time of joyfulness, celebration, peace, and openness to others, there can be so many who resist the idea that someone outside a particular set of beliefs could have a different perspective with its own insights. There is the longstanding tendency, of course, to politicize everything, which is just a larger form of competitiveness and the desire to be better than. In ancient times this played out in the form of war and conquest. Yet every great civilization ultimately failed as rulers overreached and could not sustain their grasp. The cultures they tried to assimilate ultimately assimilated them.
Perhaps there is no one and only way. Teachers come and go and new insights are built on old ones. This has been the history of the world and the cultural history of humanity. Many of the great traditions live on, but they are not what they once were. Some traditions are maintained but others change and new ones take their place. Perhaps we should look more closely at nature to see how it changes and adapts unless it is s stressed that it can adapt no longer. There should be important lessons there some of which different cultures have made part of their experience but then new toys become distractions and the insights fade. This is a good time of year to reflect.
Posted on 12/4/2016 6:34:19 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Christmas season is one of the most enjoyable times of the year and one of my favorites. The focus on peace, the phrase “peace on Earth,” being central to this time of year should, of course, be thematic all year long. In the West, Christmas has, like art, become very commercial, and that focus can add an air of artificiality to many public spaces. Still, the proliferation of decorations, lights, and background music is not unpleasant if sometimes a bit tacky. The peripheral mythology that accompanies Christmas has become quite eclectic, and it too has also become quite commercial. Even so, many churches put on musical celebrations and programs that can be entertaining as well as spiritually uplifting.
Through the years my wife and I have collected a variety of ornaments that grace the tree that we always have even when for several years we used a bamboo palm instead of the traditional conifer. The ornaments are indeed representative of the world at large, some gleaned from our own travels or from the travels of friends who have gifted us with their stories and mementos of their journeys. I have my favorites among these which include some personally handmade ones. Many countries are represented. I love the carved bone seal pups from the Soviet Union that I found there in the late eighties. From that same trip, I have ornaments from Finland and England. Several specific peace ornaments come from Rwanda, Japan, Thailand, China, and Polynesia. My favorite among these is an ornamental ball hand-painted by a Tibetan monk from Nepal. It is truly an exquisite piece of craftsmanship and history since the friend who brought it to us died some years ago. Most of the Scandinavian countries are represented in wicker and woven ornaments: Sweden, Denmark, Norway, and Finland mentioned earlier. I also love the hand-painted ornaments from Bulgaria and the eggs from Ukraine.
Among the religions represented are Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, Taoism, and Islam. There is no discrimination in our household, which to me is in keeping with the spirit of the holiday even though it is a Christian one. I have never accepted the exclusionary tenets of religious principles, which would be incompatible to a loving, forgiving God. I believe in the universality of the Creative Spirit.
Posted on 12/3/2016 6:46:54 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A metaphor is an imaginative comparison that we often find in poetry or what we call poetic language. In the visual arts, especially in painting, we tend to think of symbolic expression and encounter objects used as symbols that represent something else. Jasper Johns’ series of American flags, for example, were not symbolic as such for he used the flag not for its symbolic content unless we say it is a subtext, but for its emblematic quality and visual reality – that is, a flag is a flat piece of cloth. Johns and other American painters were exploring the idea that a painting is a flat object that has no dimension and therefore any subject matter should conform to the idea to keep it real as opposed to illusionistic painting that would suggest illusory depth and space. Some modern painters of the nineteen sixties and seventies considered anything dimensional in painting as a visual lie. We could say that the idea of making the painting only be about flatness was a major conceit of that period in twentieth century art.
A flag, of course, contains levels of symbolism. The American flag represents the republic and the nation as a whole. Thirteen stripes for the original thirteen colonies that banded into a single country independent from England, the original flag also contained a star for each state in the union symbolized by the field of blue on which the stars were placed, and the red and white stripes to symbolize courage, purity, and innocence. Again, Johns’ flags had no such symbolic content and did not use the traditional colors. The image was part of the culture, readily available, consistent with flatness, and simply served as a subject appropriate to the concept of a flat painting. He used alphabetical letters and numbers for the same purpose. Neither letters nor numbers have appreciable dimension beyond their obvious two-dimensional character.
One could argue that what Johns did, and others in their own ways, was a form of conceited behavior, meaning that they thought their work was the appropriate modern answer to five hundred or so years of illusionistic painting. Johns took ordinary, unpainterly ‘objects’ and made them serious subjects for art (although there may have been an element of tongue in cheek as well). Many artists exhibit an inflated sense of importance, call it conceit if you will, but this is a human characteristic that is not limited to the arts.
Earlier I used the word conceit to refer to the kind of idea that Johns and others were exploring in painting, the idea of flatness. As used later, conceit can also mean an exaggerated sense of importance or egotism. In literature, especially in poetry, conceit also means an exaggerated comparison that builds a complex metaphorical relationship between the objects compared. An extended metaphor that might run through an entire poem like the blue guitar in Wallace Stevens’ “The Man with the Blue Guitar” where that colored guitar represents creative expression is an example of conceit. Shakespeare and other Elizabethan writers often used conceit in poems and plays. Romeo’s soliloquy as he watches Juliet at her window when he exclaims that she is the sun uses celestial imagery as conceit.
The best painters throughout history have employed conceit in one form or another in their work. They represent ideas, conceits, and utilize some again and again for these are part of their artistic concern. An artist’s approach to painting or to art can be seen as conceit. Whistler’s Nocturnes are a good example of visual conceit as he explored expressions in a series that other artists might only do in one or two works. Conceits as ideas are the underpinning of much art, and we shouldn’t necessarily assume that the artist is also conceited just because he or she believes that the art is good.
Posted on 12/2/2016 8:13:42 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A backyard journey reveals multiple layers of reality that we choose to believe is one extensive whole. Everything we experience, however, is made up of multiple fragments that our minds trick us into thinking are continuous, seamless, and infinite even though our vision and focus are finite. Memory ties together the mini-dramas that we broadcast via the internet of our brains, those billions of neural connections that like the stars we can only presume to understand. The stars we see and acknowledge yet we may also have some inkling that we cannot ever go there because the distance to the nearest outside our solar system is many of our lifetimes distant – even though we can see them and measure some of their properties.
Science fiction conceives of distant space travel by placing crews in hibernation. In their subconscious/unconscious stasis, those travelers may even exceed the real-time years of their lives, yet when they waken, perhaps generations later upon arrival at their destination, they will only feel a few moments older than when they went to sleep. We do not possess the technology for such hibernation much less the propulsion systems to send travelers those great distances, but it is not unlikely that the time will come when such travel is possible. For the moment, we are like infants just beginning to teeth and not too stable on our legs.
Would that what we imagine so easily could manifest as readily. Perhaps there is something here that entices the artistically inclined to explore those fantasies and dreams as a way of stretching the limited reality we know into something more meaningful than groups of sentient beings struggling to survive, challenging each other, and sometimes subsisting at the expense of others less accomplished whether in size, strength, speed, or wit. Are our entertainments sophisticated distractions from the harshness of our lot, or are these indeed pathways to deeper understanding and communion with the energetic underpinning that binds us all together whether we like it or not? Some might say that since we’re thinking we might as well think positively and proactively, make the most of what we have. Why speculate on doom and gloom and the inevitability of endings? We cannot ignore, though, the change that occurs whether we wish it otherwise.
Somewhere between hope and despair there is the mystery of spiritual understanding. We look to some transcendent benevolence and claim our alignment with that power, for it is far greater than what any of us can conceive. Or is that not true? We do conceive it, perhaps even conceived it, which may be the likelier case since there are many versions all vying for the ultimate expression. That is very human-like and has been the history of our species even before we were able to record it with some semblance of accuracy, that is, the outdoing of one another with something grander or more powerful or more inclusive, and sometimes more sinister. The seasons change; there is death and renewal; the old gives way to the new even as now we wind down the year soon to reach the solstice and shortly thereafter, rebirth into the New Year. Traditions converge around this time, and we find artistic manifestations of customs, rituals, and devotions that carry us generation after generation like echoes in some vast cosmic chasm.
Posted on 12/1/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Throughout art history there have been artist noted for their unique visions that deviated significantly from that of their contemporaries. Van Gogh always comes to mind easily, but if we step back in time, we might also think of El Greco whose elongated painterly figures were significantly different from the seemingly more polished work of his contemporaries. Was there some visual problem or other perceptual deviance that made him so different? That is hard to say. One thing that is obvious is that there is consistency in his work, so he definitely had specific skill to do what he did over and over.
Anyone looking a Van Gogh’s early work will also see that he reached a stage in his early development when he consistently painted beautiful painterly landscapes that could rival any of the Barbizon school or other pre-Impressionist landscape painters. Once he began to explore his signature style, those energetic, stylized, heavily pigmented pictures, he did so with great passion, intensity, and consistency. These were not flukes of a disturbed mind.
Pissarro explored different stylistic expressions yet all his canvasses are clearly constructed and well-executed whether in the looser plein air style or the more confined pointillism that he experimented with for several years. We could also mention the late work of Degas, especially the pastel paintings, the late work of Renoir when his hands betrayed him and his eyesight was failing, or the late work of Monet that seemed to move towards abstraction but could have been the result of failing eyesight as well. Some critics do include these medical diagnoses as part of their criticism, but I’m not so sure that is a fair assessment.
The work of any artist may change at any time from choice or from some shift in perceptual insight. An artist can take a physical challenge and turn that to his or her advantage, for the sensibility is there still. The artist will adjust expression to the change in ability or other situational challenge. Think of those wonderful paper cut-outs that Matisse created when he was confined to bed or the amazing small flower paintings that Manet painted when he likewise was confined to bed. What about the German painter Lovis Corinth who continued to paint after suffering a stroke that affected his work, altering it from what it once was, but also allowing him to explore a new experience of visual perception that gave us wonderfully expressive drawings and paintings we might otherwise not have ever seen?
Perhaps we should take care in how we judge what others do. Is the late Rembrandt any less vital and expressive than the early, virile one, or just the opposite? Does Picasso become less expressive and inventive after Guernica? Some of the aforementioned artists did reach a time when they could no longer paint because of poor vision or physical disability, but do we count those waning years (and work) as a decline or simply an exploration of a new phase and new opportunities for discovery? Is that paint tube half full or half empty?