Blog
Idol Curiosity
Posted on 12/21/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Creative Process | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Mystic Shades
There is a curious debate that has been going on in art for some time between artists who practice realism and those who practice abstraction. It may be thought that realistic portrayal of things in the world is the older of the two approaches to picture making, but I’m not so sure. Evidence of those magnificent cave paintings that date back forty to fifty thousand years are very realistic portrayals of animals, to be sure, although sometimes simplified but still very animated and lifelike. The best examples are in the twenty to forty thousand year range, and question remains whether there may be more undiscovered examples that could be much older. These likely didn’t develop full blown from some prehistoric artist’s imagination; there would have been development of forms and ways of rendering over time. Wouldn’t there? At least that’s what we are used to seeing within the range of recorded history. Pictorial representations have dominated historical art forms since the most ancient of civilizations, and Western art is built on the Ancient and Classical worlds.
However, those ancient shells found in Indonesia that have carved zigzag patterns on them are half a million years old (“Zigzags on a Shell from Java Are the Oldest Human Engravings,” Smithsonian, December 2014). This is a very strong argument that at least some hominids made abstract designs several hundred thousand years before any realistic images showed up in paintings or sculpture. Obviously, what prehistoric ancestors did as designs or some kind of decorative imagery are far removed from historical concepts of art of civilized ancient times and more so removed from concepts of the past five hundred years where artistic expression became a form of high art rather than simply decorative art. This evidence might persuade some that abstract design is older than realistic design, but does it really matter?
The question upon which the argument for one side or the other is based has to do with which has greater legitimacy (or truth) as art. Is this really an important question to ask? If we think about how a visual artist learns and uses the traditional apprenticeship model, we would see that young artists in training copied from the master’s work or made detailed drawings of studio objects in chalk or charcoal – not in color and not using paints. Even today artists do variations on this idea in drawing classes all over the world. So, aren’t these students already abstracting what they see if they are only working in black and white? Students are taught to see large masses, simplified forms, simple contrast between light and dark, and to focus on shapes rather than objects. Get the formal relationships right among contrasts, textures, shapes, and position, and the ‘object’ will emerge from that set of relationships. This is abstraction at its core. Students learn to draw realistically by training themselves to see abstract forms.
Abstract artists will say some variation of the idea that all art is abstract anyway. It is a semblance of something and not the thing itself. Even an abstract painting is composed of arranged materials that – it could be argued – have little to do with the resulting painting other than being component parts. The integrated whole of the work whether realistic or abstract is what comprises the art and not the ingredients, subject matter, or how those parts were manipulated. Criticism has taught us to abstract in reverse by deconstructing an art work whether visual, literary, performance, or otherwise. We take it apart to see how it works, or so we think, and then piece together ideas about its validity, veracity, or value. That can be theoretically interesting, but it does not get to the experience of the work: how someone feels when confronting a piece of art in the first place.
Leave a Comment