Blog
Looking and Responding
Posted on 1/27/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Spirituality | Thoughts on Art

There are many ways to respond to any work of art. This is so variable that we would have to discuss a specific work and consider the kinds of responses a viewer might have to that work. What we could say generally about response to most kinds of art would be quite broad but also worth considering. First, most viewers likely would respond emotionally to an art work. He or she could feel elated, excited, intrigued (all on the attractive or positive side), or, if repulsed, this could range from abhorrence to fear, anger, or all the way to simple, plain indifference. Whatever the emotion, a viewer could do well to ask what might be the cause of the emotion felt. In other words, why do I respond to this piece in such an intense way (or not at all)?
In effect, the viewer is now beginning to engage with the work by noticing not only what can be experienced in the work itself, but also what is experienced internally on a personal level. This requires some amount of self-awareness and the willingness to look inward, to question one’s thoughts, feelings, and biases.
It has been said that art is a mirror, which makes sense if we consider the clichés like “beauty is in the eye of the beholder” or “everyone sees things differently.” The viewer always brings his or her experience and knowledge to any work, and these thoughts are in a sense reflected by the art work (in the viewer’s response to the work). We could say that the viewer and the art are engaged in a discussion of sorts – the art provides the prompt and the viewer responds to that.
What can be most special are those works that stay with us after we have moved on to other activities. Related images or ideas may pop into the mind at any time after the initial experience, and these prompt further deliberation. It is as though we’re on a process of discovery, which can include self-discovery. Again, every work is different as is every viewer, but we may describe some works as having great emotional power. Take Mark Rothko’s late work as an example. Specifically, consider the so-called black paintings in Houston’s Rothko Chapel. The art work was designed to create a visual surround experience. The mural-sized paintings enclose viewers on four sides in the small space (roughly 52 feet by 56 feet). Benches are placed facing the four walls so viewers can sit and meditate or pray, but they also can walk around within the space and view the paintings from up close.
Because these paintings may initially appear somber, some critics have suggested that they reflect Rothko’s depressed state of mind towards the end of his life. The paintings, however, are not literally black. They are done in muted tones of purple and blue and only sometimes appear blackish. As with other large-scale Rothko paintings that tend towards monochrome, a patient viewer will notice many subtle shifts of tone in the works. There is no literal image, simply a large field of color. These paintings in particular, rather than project sadness or depression, serve as a backdrop for contemplation. I would suggest that a viewer is invited to merge with the color field and go on a deep meditative and spiritual journey in the presence of these works. The mood is subdued rather than somber, calming rather than depressing.
Since I have lived in Houston for more than thirty years, I have seen these paintings many times. I also have talked with people coming into and out of the Chapel to discover their reactions. I have never heard one speak of being depressed after seeing the paintings. To do a full-fledged sociological study, of course, it would be important to know about backgrounds of viewers, their expectations going in, and their responses after coming out. Do viewers go to the Chapel to meditate or pray, do they go out of curiosity, do they go specifically to see the paintings, or what other reasons might they have for going? We could ask similar questions of viewers going to a museum or gallery. An artist may not care as long as people look at the work. Response to work is always going to be personal anyway, but isn’t that true for everything ultimately?
Leave a Comment