Blog
A Shot in the Dark
Posted on 2/13/2016 5:01:30 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Painting Technique | Philosophy | Sculpture | Thoughts on Art

Back in the sixties, within the U.S. in particular, artists began to experiment with various combinations of techniques including performance. Some painters moved beyond painting by making painting one element of an artwork rather than the focus. At events called Happenings a kind of contrived spontaneity held sway, contrived because the event was to some extent pre-planned. Sculptors began to work with the environment – those who worked in nature were called environmental sculptors; others worked within a given space like a room or gallery to create an experience for the viewer (who became a participant within the space). All sorts of philosophical explanations and justifications grew up around these experiments.
Traditional painting including most abstract painting is two-dimensional and any suggestion of space and depth are illusory, created with perspective and the manipulation of color and texture. Sculpture has traditionally been three-dimensional requiring movement in space on the part of the audience to fully appreciate the work from all sides. Some critics have suggested that painting is experienced all at once in the moment and that sculpture takes time to appreciate since the viewer must physically move. Of course, a painting can be contemplated, which in itself takes time, and if one is to fully appreciate a painting, this often includes thinking about it and possibly researching aspects of it. Again, this takes time. Therefore, in my mind, time is not such a distinctive factor between the experience of painting and sculpture.
When a sculpture is environmental, and we could use formal gardens as examples of environmental sculpture that existed before visual artist sculptors appropriated the concept as something new and modern, a viewer actually enters into the work and is surrounded by it. This is like our experience of any physical space we may encounter in nature or within man-made space like architecture or a city. The environmental artist thinks about controlling the space much like a painter might control the two-dimensional surface of paper or canvas. Some environmental artists have expressed their desire to force the viewer to confront or focus his/her attention on the experience of experiencing whatever is in the space. This would be to make him or her aware of something not normally paid attention to. As with any art, however, the artist’s control over what a viewer may think or feel in the presence of a work is pretty limited. The work is there to be viewed, to be engaged with, to be dismissed, or to be ignored.
Artistic ideas can be appealing, exciting, invigorating, and engaging, or they can be so obscure and obtuse as to keep a viewer from experiencing any positive emotional or intellectual connection. Perhaps the distinction is in the same realm as a discussion about concepts like beauty or interesting. What makes something beautiful? What makes something interesting? Perhaps, too, in the final analysis, the artist is beholden to the beholder.
Leave a Comment