Blog
Covering Up
Posted on 3/2/2016 2:39:09 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art in Life | Art in nature | Education | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Many years ago in an art class, I worked slavishly on a painting assignment. The process was slow, and I became self-conscious when I realized the instructor was standing behind me watching what I was doing. I became a bit nervous thinking about whether each decision and stroke I made were ones that he might make. Finally, as I stood looking at the mess before me, he stepped up and put a hand on my shoulder. “Relax,” he said. “Don’t be afraid to cover up what’s already there. If you worry about losing something, you won’t get anything else right. Trust your observation and trust the process.”
I’ve thought about those words many times while working on my own paintings. I also find myself thinking of them as I watch students struggling with their painted images. Novice students often paint as though they want the image to pop out on the first or second stroke. They want to paint everything at once without respect to the demands of the medium. They try to short circuit the process.
Painting is a process. The general approach is to start thin and thicken as you go. Whether the paint becomes very thick or not, the basic idea with oil painting is that it is done in layers. Things do get covered up. They’re supposed to; it’s part of the process. The comfort that some may take in a carefully placed drawing often turns to frustration as a painting progresses. The tyranny of those explicit lines becomes restrictive and results in what might be called coloring book paintings. So much time and care is spent trying to paint inside the lines that color and edges suffer, and harmony is lost. The resultant painting is little more than a colored drawing.
I don’t mean to imply that meticulous painting is not good painting. Certainly, meticulous painters like Durer or Ingres produced masterpieces with regularity. They did so because they understood the painting process and how to make it serve their visions. My guess, though, is that most painters are not meticulous painters. Their intent has more to do with expressive, impressionistic, or loosely painted images that allow for flexibility, response to changing light conditions, or discoveries that may not have been anticipated at the outset. However, style is not the issue. That a painting proceeds according to certain steps is the issue at hand, and those steps include covering up something that was previously painted.
Oil paint is designed to show its best qualities when applied in successive layers. Artists understood that oils tend towards transparency over time. The idea of underpainting was used by painters for hundreds of years to enhance the appearance of the end product. The warm, glowing light associated with Rembrandt’s painting is the result of warm, light values painted first in areas where illumination was most desired. His paintings often have a luminosity that verges on the magical. Most of the Flemish painters used layering to achieve a wide range of textural effects in complex still life paintings, portraiture, and interior scenes. Only in the 19th century did painters begin to experiment with layering in ways that did not rely so much on traditional thin layers and glazing. Plein air painting required a more direct approach and wet into wet techniques became staples in the painter’s arsenal.
Direct painting as practiced by plein air painters and others doesn’t eliminate layering. The technique is simply modified in various ways. Some painters will tone their boards or canvases ahead of time with warm, cool, or neutral tones so as to be prepared for various conditions. Some will thinly paint an image rather than create an outline drawing, and then work heavier applications of color into the thin paint. Appropriately placed lighter or darker accents may then come on top of these. One friend of mine loosely covers the canvas with medium to dark paint thinned with oil medium rather than turp, and then uses a rag to wipe certain areas that will be lighter in the composition. He then proceeds with thicker applications of color. The variety of possibilities may not be endless with direct painting, but they certainly are sufficient to meet the creative applications of most artists.
One piece of advice that I’ve heard many times from many sources is to get rid of the white background. It is very difficult to see color accurately against white. Even if one weren’t familiar with Josef Albers’ experiments with color, painters do know about color’s relativity. The goal after all is to harmonize colors while creating the image. Toning a canvas in preparation for painting, or painting in the big shapes first, will both lay down that initial layer of color and set the stage for the great cover-up. What happens next is up to the individual painter.
Leave a Comment