Blog
Notes on the Work of a Painter
Posted on 3/20/2016 5:19:23 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Rosenquist - Gift-Wrapped Doll
I’ve never cared much for the paintings of James Rosenquist. I could say the same for many of the Pop Art practitioners. I am aware that sometimes there is social criticism, satire, and anti-consumerism as part of some of these works. I’m also aware of the links to different periods of art history and some philosophical perspectives shared with Renaissance painting, Dutch painting, and periods of academic painting. Influences on any artist are always filtered through subjective screens, which is why we can see very different work coming from two artists claiming to have been influenced by the same painter or same type of art.
The images of much Pop Art are not very interesting to me, and their frequent huge scale demands a mural-size induced flatness and simplification that to me is not appealing. I’ve seen many of Rosenquist’s original paintings, so I’m not simply responding to reproduced images that totally distort scale. I’ve also seen at least two versions of the famous F-111 that is often among those images reproduced.
Perhaps the close proximity of much Pop Art to commercial advertising (a world from which Rosenquist came as a billboard painter but also student of art) is part of the issue for me. Perhaps it is the audacity of the large images meant to influence from a distance, not the normal viewing distance of painting (but what is the normal viewing distance of art intended to fill large spaces?). Perhaps it is the kitschy appearance of so much of this kind of painting that annoys me. I do recognize my biases and admit to them.
Currently, though, I’m reading Painting below Zero: Notes on a life in Art by James Rosenquist and David Dalton that a friend loaned to me. Rosenquist’s story is interesting and reminds me of many shared experiences of life during the mid-twentieth century. I understand better where his art come from, that his story is a personal one and not one fabricated by critics to enhance the cachet of a particular art movement. The latter is a specific danger to which western art has been subjected for a great many generations. It is part of the price of living and working within a particular culture. Just as ordinary people are influenced by the machinations of their leaders and others in positions of power, so is everyone influenced by any number of cultural and social forces regardless how independent we may think ourselves.
One group of Rosenquist works I do find interesting and engaging is the series of gift-wrapped dolls from the 1990’s. These images are colorful, well-painted, convincingly illusionistic, and carry a complex metaphorical dimension – the images are portions of the dolls, mostly heads, that appear to be wrapped in cellophane or plastic (as preserved objects rather than gifts since gifts would normally be hidden by wrappers). Dolls are prime examples of consumerism as playthings for children (also often must-have items that can become collectibles, possibly a reference to art). They are stylized figures already, so they are perfect as Pop images. They are symbols of imaginative play while referencing the innocence of childhood. Yet, Rosenquist presents them sometimes in an almost menacing way (no overt reference to Stephen King), perhaps to suggest the indoctrination of children to gender roles or the expectations of parents. Personally, I find these paintings much more satisfying than the grandiose murals that have become icons of the Pop Art movement.
I do applaud Rosenquist for his accomplishments and for his contributions to twentieth century American painting. There are many who do enjoy and appreciate his work. Every artist has the right to follow his or her muse wherever that may lead. Others may or may not follow. It is certain that along the way there will be many critics.
Leave a Comment