Blog
Am I Nuts, or What?
Posted on 3/31/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Language | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Literature | Metaphor | Philosophy | Sculpture | Thoughts on Art | Writing

Art history courses give little more than an overview of what has taken place in the history of art. Typically, within any given time period, which starts out early on considering thousands of years, then is concentrated within centuries down to a single century, and ultimately to a movement that spans less than a generation, we might see a dozen or more works that represent any of those periods. A single artist, however, could easily create hundreds of works within his or her lifetime, and of those a small number could be considered masterpieces or, if that term is too grandiose, then we say mature works. It is little wonder that many of us carry around a skewed version of what has been done in art over the centuries.
Compare the visual artist to the literary artist, particularly a novelist, who might pen anywhere from one to a dozen or more books within that same working period of time. A single work could make the reputation of a writer – think of writers as disparate as Melville with Moby Dick and Salinger with A Catcher in the Rye. Melville is often credited with having written the great American novel, and yet most people would be hard pressed to name another work by his hand. Harper Lee wrote one major work in To Kill a Mockingbird and then retired from the literary scene that she never actually fit into to begin with. The jury is still out on the supposed second novel that she may never have intended to see published.
There are few painters that are known for a single work. We might think of Leonardo and the Mona Lisa, or Michelangelo and the Sistine Chapel ceiling, but the former is also widely known for his inventive work and some other paintings (especially by those who know something of the Renaissance) and the latter is known as much for his sculpture as for his painting (David, of course). Without too much difficulty, we could find other examples of paintings by these and other masters. Even when working with the big names of art, it is in the details that the real history is told. Every artist had a life and worked every day, perhaps without even thinking so much about how he might be remembered (although also quite aware of those artists that preceded and transferred their influence).
Still, we can’t see only one Cubist painting and comprehend all the assumptions underlying the whys and wherefores of these paintings. Museums will often focus on a time period or on select works by a single artist in order to show more depth to the work and contribute to the understanding of the particular artist’s oeuvre or body of work. Any single painting may be an important component of that work, and that painting may be fully appreciated as a singular work of art. Even so, it may be perceived differently when placed in the context of other works done within the same year or within a brief span of years on either side of that one piece. It is my contention that painting, more so than literature, is created within a context and that pieces relate to other pieces as parts of a larger statement about art (for that artist).
There could be a lengthy discussion here about style, the painter’s handwriting, the painter’s palette, the choice of subjects, and the many other factors that contribute to what makes one painter different from another. Soon the critique of the work would look like any critique of any other maker of art in any medium since we’d be considering many of the same types of influences that artists tend to experience: the work of predecessors, the time within which they work, social and cultural issues, specific artistic concerns, and the overall pattern of art history. We’d also have to ask the question of the artist, is it the individual work that matters most or is it that work in context of the entire body of work that matters? Is it what takes place in the moment of creation or in that moment related to all other creative moments? Can the artist truthfully answer that question him or herself? Personally, I’m not so sure.
Leave a Comment