Blog
Making the Choice
Posted on 5/11/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

“A well-composed painting is half done.” (Pierre Bonnard)
“Composition is the art of controlling the observer.” (Robert Henri)
“A composition is the organized sum of the interior functions of every part of the work.” (Wassily Kandinsky)
Yesterday’s The Painter’s Keys newsletter was from a 2005 post that discussed the idea of handedness in composition, whether a design is right- or left-weighted. In the postscripts Robert listed several quotations from artists about composition emphasizing its importance and its ability to influence the viewer (a few of these above). Through hundreds of years of painting many principles have been developed to assist artists in utilizing the particular space of a painting regardless of the traditional rectangular format, vertical or horizontal, its variant the evenly matched square, or some other variation such as a circle or oval. Some painters after the middle of the twentieth century began to experiment with shaped canvasses, which introduce a different set of design problems. But even these painters were not the first to paint on surfaces non-rectangular. There are ceiling murals in circular buildings, thousands of examples of paintings on vases and other irregular surfaces some of which date back thousands of years.
Every artist is faced with design choices and likely also develops working methods to tackle whatever design problems are presented to him or her or are imagined in the process of creating works. Ideas like creating a center of interest, using the golden mean, following the rule of thirds, considering symmetrical or asymmetrical placement, using repetition, similar or contrasting shapes, and others can and have been used by themselves or in combination to create compositions. Whatever choices an artist makes have to work with all design elements and support the subject in order to make a successful outcome. Learning to use the many options available is part of the artist’s creative development, and for this there are no shortcuts. It simply takes a lot of painting and a lot of looking at other paintings to develop sensitivity to design and placement.
I particularly like the statement from Henri Matisse, “A work of art is a collection of signs invented during execution to suit the needs of their position.” This fits well with my own thinking about how a painting develops. The focus is on the process of a painting becoming what it is intended to be. While painting, the painter makes whatever signs (colors, shapes, strokes) are needed to fulfill the purpose of the work as it exists within the creative imagination. I often think about a dialog taking place between me and the painting each time something new is added. Every decision followed by action determines the next decision and the next action until a kind of conclusive compromise is achieved, the compromise being that no further action is required. The painting and I are in agreement. If anyone objects to anthropomorphizing the painting, just consider that we often say a work comes to life, is full of life, or feels alive for the viewer who interacts with it.
I also think it important to live with a piece of art for a while before totally deciding that it is complete. Sometimes a work has called for a change, either something added or something taken away, which was not noticed in the heat of the original creative process. This, too, is part of that natural development of the painting coming into being and the artistic voice becoming manifest.
Leave a Comment