Blog
Cultural Challenge
Posted on 10/3/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Criticism | Education | Ethics | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art | Writing

We in America, and perhaps all the West, live ironically. We encourage learning, not for its own sake or to become conscious, educated beings, but in order to be competitive on the world stage. We worship athletes and create a system whereby young, uneducated, but physically gifted boys can grow into men of substance (not so much for girls although this may very slowly be changing), be praised for their prowess and leave the slums behind ultimately to hawk underwear and motor oil when their knees no longer can support them on the field of glory. Athletics in schools get the lion’s share of investment while the arts shiver in rags or go begging with their tin cups in hand. We create a health system that is the envy of the world, but only the wealthy can afford to utilize it to the fullest. Meanwhile, the young suffer increases in respiratory, immune system, and diabetic illnesses and decline in general levels of fitness. We give rights and freedom to everyone and incarcerate more of our citizens, especially the poor and less educated, than any other country. In what is supposed to be the world’s greatest democracy, we invest most of the wealth and power in the hands of the 1%. In short, we are a land of paradoxes.
The arts have addressed some of these issues, most effectively, perhaps, in writing and drama or in film, for the visual arts have become less well suited for social criticism in an age of the internet and virtual communication. We have great examples of social criticism from the past, but even these we might wonder about their impact at the time they were created: Goya, for example, in his war etchings or in his late so-called black paintings, works by Picasso, Grosz, the Dadaists, and many forms of outsider art. How widely known were they at the time of their creation? Though some of these works may end up in art history texts or in museums, it is in the realm of criticism and historical writing that they are most widely known. Guernica is something of an exception, for there is no other singular work so well known in modern art.
Every piece of art is an expression of the subject in the context of the values, culture, and events of its specific era, but in modern times as art has become increasingly commercial and the collector market has spiraled out of control, work that criticizes the very culture that it comes from is not popular within that culture. Chinese artist Ai Weiwei, for example, is known internationally for his art and his activism in criticizing human rights violations in China. In spite of difficulties with the Chinese government including months in prison, he continues to work in a broad range of mediums, but his stature internationally is much higher than at home where he is seen as a troublemaker. Would collectors and patrons support his work for its artistic value or for his activism against a totalitarian regime? This is part of the dilemma with political art. Its social impact has to be political and cultural; otherwise it is not significant work – it does not achieve its purpose. This is very different from art that is primarily emotional, intellectual, and is about art and artistic ideas.
Where is the artist in this cultural mix? Can we say that Al Weiwei is more dedicated to his art or to his social criticism? We might argue that there is no separation between the two concerns. Not all of Weiwei’s art is overtly political, however, and what is political is art that happens to express a political/cultural message. He is, after all, an artist, and art would be his natural voice. Isn’t it fair to say that most artists keep politics out of art, for their concerns are with aesthetic questions and not social or cultural ones? They may be good citizens within their respective countries and may vote or participate in cultural affairs at whatever level they choose. Their artistic voice, however, is reserved for art-related issues, And, if these artists are concerned with universal themes (those verities of the heart that William Faulkner addressed in his Nobel Prize acceptance speech), are the artists expressing a higher concern, one that may include political-social-cultural issues but is not limited to them?
I suspect that most artists have little interest in politics unless it directly affects them personally (budget cuts, censorship, or other forms of discrimination). Yet, just putting art out there in public is a form of social commentary if not a directly political statement. Isn’t it an expression of personal freedom? Isn’t it a bit subversive regardless of content? Isn’t it making some statement about the nature of reality even when seemingly innocuous like a painting of a vase of flowers or a pastoral landscape? Isn’t that freedom of expression what has always challenged authoritarian regimes whether secular or religious? Art provides an alternative perspective to whatever is the dominant point of view, and that artistic perspective can be expansive and growth-promoting or could be seen as rebellious and dissident. Art can be a bit dangerous, for it is most often advocating every person for him or herself. That can be a pretty radical idea even in societies that espouse freedom of speech and freedom of action.
Leave a Comment