Blog
Drama in Art
Posted on 11/2/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Creative Process | Criticism | Education | Film | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Literature | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Recently I’ve been viewing a detective series titled The Fall (available on Netflix) that is a BBC psychodrama starring Gillian Anderson as the detective in charge of finding and stopping a serial killer of women in Belfast. The series is gritty, intense, incredibly written, produced, and acted by the entire cast (as are many BBC productions). On American television there have been and are many popular series about doctors, hospitals, and emergency care as well as many police dramas. Some of these are interesting from what I’ve seen (NYPD Blue was one of the best), but American dramas almost make the most serious stories into cartoon like renderings. There will be attempts at realism, but there is always something to take the edge off and often to provide comic relief. This happens frequently in American film as well. If we look at American literature, however, it is often at a much higher level of artistry that rarely translates satisfactorily into film.
In a recent episode of The Fall, the serial killer is shot while in police custody (the details are not important to my point here) and is taken to the emergency room and later into surgery. Years ago I worked in a state hospital emergency room for almost three years and know very well how that setting is works day in and day out. I’ve rarely seen anything portrayed on television that captures the essence of emergency medicine, but this BBC episode was pitch perfect. The medical team did not play their roles comedically like an episode of Mash, but there was some wry humor, or with the staged character challenges of ER or other like-minded shows. This was real-life drama with an expert team of medical professionals working intensely to save a person’s life. The same was true after the patient was stabilized enough for surgery, and the surgical team worked with precision and professionalism even when one or two were faced with doubt. These medical scenes were as tightly crafted as any of the often brutal murder scenes, which made the irony of the situation even more dramatic since doctors and nurses were fighting as hard to save the killer’s life as he fought in killing his victims (there was often a perverse precision in his actions).
I don’t care that much for violent shows or stories, but I have trained long enough in various aspects of art to understand aesthetic distance. I can be engaged and disengaged at the same time. I can be emotionally involved but also sensitive to critical insight, especially points where there are rifts in the fabric of the tale, a disruption of the narrative that causes the reality of the art to buckle.
Not all art, of course, is necessarily attempting to portray the brutality or the derangement found in the world. Much of it is uplifting while also maintaining a tightly crafted structure that supports the subject or the message when there is one. Examples could range from Rembrandt to Warhol or from Michelangelo to Rothko. There is no one style or subject or other manner of representation that holds a singular truth – at least, in my opinion. When the art does what the artist or artists intended, and when that intention is of a higher order (not just simple entertainment), then the audience will be transported to the reality of the work and come out the other side, so to speak, changed for the better if not also enlightened.
Leave a Comment