Blog
Another Look
Posted on 1/7/2017 7:22:35 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Returned to the exhibit Degas: A New Vision at the MFAH, which closes in about a week. A painter friend went with me, always a great way to gain from an exhibit by sharing insights and discussing problematic issues that inevitably are evident in any painter’s work. All of us do things that sometimes don’t work as planned or create results that are enigmatic at best.
We tend to think of the masters as always being masterful, but even greatness can have flaws or give rise to question, a reminder perhaps that each of us should be diligent about what we show. With a retrospective exhibit like this one, there is the possibility of works being shown that the artist never intended to show. For example, there is a large painting that is an energetic brush drawing on canvas approximately four by six feet. It is sepia-toned like one would expect in a small drawing on paper, and the suggestion is that this shows Degas’s increasing interest in black and white work (which he explored extensively in drawing, printmaking, and photography). This could also simply be the beginning of a canvas that he never completed because of numerous reasons: he felt it was complete – maybe, but there is only one other example of such a work and it is much sketchier and seems unfinished; he didn’t like where it was going and abandoned it; he was distracted by other concerns and lost interest or never found time to complete it; he wanted to leave something that showed how he began a painting (but why such a large one for that purpose?); this was the beginning of a new direction based on graphic work he wanted to explore but for whatever reason did not go beyond this singular work.
The accompanying label text to the 1884-86 work states the following:
"This remarkable, outsized canvas has stumped art historians since it appeared a century ago at Degas’s posthumous studio sales. It is the third-largest work Degas painted. The subject and composition relate both to the monotypes of bathers he made in the mid-1870s, as well as to the series of pastel nude bathers that he exhibited at the 1886 Impressionist Exhibition. The painting is likely an unfinished work, one that shows the sepia underdrawing that probably exists under all of Degas’s oil paintings made after his development of the related monotype technique that so effectively rendered light and shadow. Nevertheless, Nude Woman Drying Herself is a very satisfying picture, which may explain why Degas left it at this stage. In the late 1870s, Degas told his friends that he wanted to work exclusively in black and white, and this work is proof of that desire."
I’m not suggesting that this work is flawed, but it is quite unusual in the context of his output. As can be seen, the painting (it’s definitely not a drawing) is quite energetic and very powerful as a composition that to the modernist eye is expressive, suggestive, immediate, ambiguous, and intriguing, and to me, at least, does not in any way feel unfinished. Whatever Degas’s reasons for leaving the painting at this stage and for not making others in this vein, I am grateful to experience this one, a significant piece that no doubt has influenced many modern painters (if not directly then certainly through the related graphic work – consider Picasso’s or Matisse’s work in black and white or monotone that immediately come to mind). This is indeed a ‘very satisfying picture’ that enriches our view of a remarkable painter whose artistic impact continues.

Nude Woman Drying Herself, 1884-86
Brooklyn Museum, New York
Leave a Comment