Blog
As a Rule
Posted on 2/2/2017
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Criticism | Ethics | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Politics | Thoughts on Art

English students often complain that there are too many rules, the language is confusing, or it takes too much time to write something well. From the perspective of those who haven’t learned the rules, yes, I admit that there are a lot of them, but people learn very complex rules for different types of games all the time. Sometimes these rules are common sense and sometimes obscure. Like most sets of rules, however, if you understand them, you will likely be able to accomplish whatever task is needed much better, and you will also be able to resolve any unexpected problems. Also, as with other rule-driven endeavors, a practitioner will likely learn how to do something from observing others, interacting with peers, and absorbing through everyday activity. This I would call functional knowledge or functional ability where the most basic of rules are intuited, but to really understand and master the skill, it is necessary to study the topic in depth. The latter requires learning the rules that govern it.
We have a current situation in the U.S. with a new president who has no past experience in governance or statesmanship. He does not understand the rules no matter how adept he may be at working with people or acting as a leader. Plus, his brash personality leads to clashes with others, disputes over miscommunications, insults to potential allies, and, what may be the most damaging down the road, miscommunications that lead to unnecessary conflict with devastating results. Much negativity could be avoided and positive steps could be enhanced by learning basic rules of protocol. Whether that will happen remains to be seen.
Artists learn and utilize lots of rules that enable them to express their creative ideas for maximum effect. Younger artists often have a tendency to ignore rules or intentionally break rules thinking that their ideas and insights are superior to years of tradition that have produced our most valuable examples of world art. Granted some of those examples were considered rule-breakers in their time, but whatever rules were broken were done so by artists who had mastered their skills and understanding (and the rules they ultimately broke). This is different from bulldozing ahead and forcing a conclusion out of egotism or ignorance. Rules that have purpose and lead to productivity and generate some value enable the user to contribute to the larger picture and may even affect adjustment in the rules themselves. We can easily follow the process of advancement and adjustment throughout the history of art to the present time and appreciate artists for their contributions as both rule makers and as rule breakers.
Leave a Comment