Blog
Historical Thoughts
Posted on 3/7/2017
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Representational painting does not so much rely on suspension of disbelief like theater does, but it is built on how the medium, which is paint, in a sense disappears into the image and what is left is a convincing likeness that the viewer full well knows is not real, is not the thing itself, but its semblance is so convincing that other qualities may be suggested along with the image: aliveness, psychological depth, various emotions, personality, strength, vulnerability – the list could go on here for these are all human traits that may be represented along with the visage. What a viewer sees largely relies on the skill of the artist rather than the imagination of the viewer (as might be the case with abstract painting).
During the High Renaissance, painters achieved great adeptness in representing the human figure and creating expressive portraits. Titian, Leonardo, Holbein, Durer, and later Rubens, Vermeer, Rembrandt all created powerful portraits in their characteristic styles. With some examples (Leonardo and Vermeer), we find that the painted surface essentially disappears. Brushwork is so refined that it becomes invisible. Rubens and Rembrandt give us robust painting styles that use physical texture of the paint to add a different level of understanding to what a painting is. We get the same kind of convincing realism or naturalism in representing individuals, but added to that is a manner of handling paint that makes the paint itself like a character in the artistic experience.
How does Rembrandt, for example, create such realism while also emphasizing the independent textural quality of the paint? The paint stands on its own while also serving the vitality of the portraiture. We see this much later in landscape with the Impressionists and their precursors like Courbet or Corot (or slightly later with Constable or Turner in England), but it almost seems easier with landscape and still life since many different textures can be explored. Many Golden Age Dutch painters did this but did so utilizing smooth blending techniques that simulated or created illusionistic texture – what I would call visual texture. The image portrays the texture of fabric or the skin of an orange peel while the paint remains relatively smoothly blended. Rembrandt might use heavily textured paint in a portrait, for example, but the texture of which has nothing to do with the texture of the skin that is represented. Color and value and appropriate transitions of each are handled with great skill, but the paint almost belies that with unique texture except that texture does not feel intrusive or inappropriate. That is a remarkable feat.
In the early twentieth century, many more painters began to explore the physical qualities of paint which led to wide ranging experimentation with imagery as well as texture. Many of the experiments became solely about the experimentation – that was the subject of the art and it had little or nothing to do with something outside itself. This brought charges of elitism, removal from the real world, art for art’s sake, and subverting meaningful content for process. In truth, artists were asking other kinds of visual questions and exploring possibility not directly tied to observable objects or events. As always, though, the viewer ultimately gets to decide what is meaningful and time becomes the arbiter of what will have lasting effect.
Leave a Comment