Blog
Point of View Point of Contact
Posted on 5/5/2017 6:25:39 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Creative Process | Criticism | Film | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Literature | Metaphor | Music | Philosophy | Sculpture | Thoughts on Art | Writing

In art, point of view is an important organizational tool. Many stories are narrated from a first person perspective. Either a character narrator remembers a story and tells it as remembered, observes a story and tells it as it unfolds, or is completely inside his/her own mind and the story is the internal workings of that mind as that character interacts with the world. The nature of the story would be different depending on how it is told. Some stories are told by different characters in a kind of back and forth revelation as the story progresses. One of my favorite set of novels, Lawrence Durrell’s Alexandria Quartet, is basically the same story with each of the four novels narrated by a different character from that character’s point of view. The quartet is like one complex mystery with new insights revealed in each successive novel. The whole work changes the complexion and meaning of each part. Other stories may be told by a third person omniscient narrator who is not a character in the story – it is effectively the author moving freely about the story landscape and in and out of select characters’ minds and thoughts. Any of these choices for narration may have benefits or limitations.
Painting as a narrative form is much more limited than literature. Typically, only a single scene can be shown, so the viewer is only seeing part of the story as directly depicted. Take for example Rembrandt’s The Blinding of Samson. Samson’s hair has been shorn and he is held down by his captors while one is gouging out one of Samson’s eyes. In the background Delilah is running away with some of Samson’s hair. The viewer must know what has preceded this particular scene and presumably also what later occurs in order for this scene to have its most dramatic impact (although it is quite dramatic and intense as rendered). Even so, only one incident in the story of Sampson is revealed in this painting. No matter how dramatic, powerful, and horrific this painting may be, compared to the biblical story of Samson in its completeness or a 1949 filmed version Samson and Delilah with Hedy Lamarr and Victor Mature that focuses on the larger context of the story and all its political and human intrigues, we might say that the painting comes up short.
In art, however, part of the experience is in the acceptance of the limitations of the form. In theater and the dramatic arts, the concept of suspension of disbelief is a crucial one, for the audience knows full well that the stage or film experience is not a real world one. It is a portrayed fiction, yet in the hands of accomplished actors and directors, the experience can be as powerful as life itself, perhaps even more so because the audience has the option to reflect on the experience while experiencing it as well as after it. A really well-crafted theatrical work can pull an audience right into that fictional world so that everything else disappears. Who hasn’t gotten lost in the pages of a good novel or been completely swept up by a piece of music, an engaging poem, or a powerful painting? The effect these works can have on us is transforming so totally are we absorbed into their reality. Point of view is the way into that other reality whether seeing a landscape as though standing in a particular spot in space, hearing the words of someone describing a world as he or she experiences it, or in some other way seeing through the eyes of the artist whatever that artist chooses for us to see. Point of view is the access point through which we willingly pass as we step into an alternate reality, the reality of art.
Leave a Comment