Blog
Superlative
Posted on 7/24/2017
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Criticism | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

On a scale of one to ten… We live in a culture that constantly compares, constantly sets one thing or one person against another, constantly attempts to define something as a ten and everything else inferior. It is a land of superlatives. I remember those superlatives from high school, but the programming began long before that. In high school there was little more than a popularity contest because kids were not that different from each other. Some may have been a bit more motivated, but most simply hadn’t discovered who they were or what they could do. How we judge, or even if we should be judging, may or may not be as important as the judgments we make. The latter will certainly say a lot about us as the judgers.
When I think about art, which for me is all the time, I do make assessments; I attempt to evaluate the art of others and that of my own. Other art I want to appreciate for what it is and for what it may say. My art I want to evaluate in order to expand and improve. Inevitably, perhaps, there will be a judgment that something is lesser, something else better. To establish a best, however, would suggest that all art is on equal footing to begin with, but that I don’t believe to be the case. So has a pre-judgment been made to determine that idea?
I wouldn’t compare a drawing with a painting or with a print or anything else outside the same medium. It’s the old idea of comparing apples and oranges. I might prefer one fruit over another, but that is my taste and my preference only. Someone else might not like either one or might choose bananas instead. So, can we really compare the painting of one artist with another? Is Degas better than Pissarro or is Braque better than Picasso? In the twentieth century and now in the twenty-first, we find such a range of art styles, combinations of styles, and artists borrowing styles or moving from one style to another, it is difficult to keep track much less to compare one to another. Mostly, I prefer to enjoy the variety, to make the most of what each artist has to give, and to marvel at how unique and different each artist’s achievement can be.
The value of art is in its diversity and within the diversity within the diversity. In fact, there is so much availability of art through various media and the internet, and there is so much good art within all that diversity, that it is practically futile to single out one or a few as the best. Concentrating too much on one or two really limits one’s ability to experience as much as possible. Having said that, I do, like many others I'm sure, have my favorites, and, if anything, that list is growing in number of artists as well as in varieties of style.
In the twentieth century, Picasso might be considered the most noteworthy and successful of artists (inevitably someone does reach the top of the heap in one way or another). That’s not to say that he was the best artist – still a rather futile assessment. He also was the one artist that most could say they either liked or did not like his work. Or, they might have liked some of his work but didn’t like the person or the persona. His oftentimes negative relationships with women put off many people. That he embodied artistic genius, however, is rarely disputed, like him or not.
In this century, the German artist Gerhardt Richter is perhaps the closest to Picasso’s achievement in diversity of style (realism, pop, social realism, geometric abstraction, photography, expressive photo-realism, expressive abstraction), overall output, longevity, and influence in Europe and abroad. He took America’s New York School abstraction and its contemporary unique artists like Warhol, Rosenquist, Rauschenberg, and Johns and created a European (and ultimately universal) answer to and dialog with groundbreaking U.S. art. How we move forward in this wired and wireless age is exciting to contemplate.
Leave a Comment