Blog
Simple and Complex
Posted on 10/30/2017
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art History | Art in Life | Art in nature | Creative Process | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Literature | Metaphor | Philosophy | Poetry | Thoughts on Art

Many novice painting students and many untutored art appreciators will judge a painting by its inclusion of details. The more detailed a work then the more realistic it is considered and therefore the more powerful the work is judged to be. The best representational art, however, based on longevity and universal appeal over generations, incorporates detail selectively and often the artist will suggest detail rather than actually render it precisely. Good literature tends to succeed by including lots of descriptive detail. This is somewhat different from painting in that readers must imagine a world from the writer’s description rather than observe it from a painter’s perspective. The painter pictorializes so that the viewer can literally see the subject according to how the painter chooses to present it. The writer describes a scene utilizing much sensory detail in order to stimulate the reader’s senses and to enable him or her to become involved with that imaginary world. It is a kind of virtual reality that is portrayed through words. Details facilitate the writer’s bringing a subject to life. Good fantasy or science fiction writers can make those completely imaginary worlds, often alien and exotic, seem convincing and life-like. The three novels that make up Frank Herbert’s Dune trilogy are good examples of selective detail enhancing a fantastical and complex story.
Painters, especially abstract painters that are not representing something that can be observed in the physical world, will have to depend on more basic design principles (themselves already abstractions) like light-dark contrast, color contrast and harmony, directional movement, size variation, and so on. A painter, realist or abstract, makes constant choices about what to include in order to make an effective composition. Most painters will simplify subject matter in order to focus on something considered important. Hans Hoffman put it this way, “the ability to simplify means to eliminate the unnecessary so that the necessary may speak.” Paul Cézanne, often considered the father of modern painting, suggested that painters focus on reducing nature to basic forms like cylinders, cones, and spheres. The paradox here is that in order to paint something complex begin with a simple version of what it basically is. Once the simplicity is established, it may not be necessary to make it more complicated, for the essence of the thing has been achieved.
In twentieth century painting and in some literature, there was a trend towards simplicity (the abstraction of Piet Mondrian, the realism of Ben Shahn, or the poetry of William Carlos Williams as examples). As is typical of the modern era, though, there are wide swings between simplicity and complexity. The incredibly dense literary expressions of James Joyce in Ulysses and Finnegan’s Wake practically overwhelm the reader with description, word play, allusions, rambling, unpunctuated sentences, encyclopedic references, and disjointed narrative. The abstract action paintings of Jackson Pollock create dense webs of linear drips, splotches, and strings of paint with no central focus. Even the stark realism of Andrew Wyeth is built from abundance of detail seeming to include every blade of grass in a field or every grain of wood in the side of a barn. These examples seem the antithesis of simplicity.
Art generally grows from some response to the world or from a response to what it means to be alive. Nature is complex, but everything in nature grows from something simple. One seed contains everything necessary to manifest a plant. Single cells combine to create the most complex creatures. Language develops from articulated sounds and symbols that name and eventually describe sensations and experiences. We, as humans, build complexity from simplicity and when faced with complexity reduce it to simpler terms in order to better understand. It should be no surprise that our artistic expression encompasses both the simple and the complex.
Leave a Comment