Blog
Abstract Realism or Realistic Abstraction
Posted on 11/10/2017 6:34:55 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Art in nature | Creative Process | Criticism | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Making Paintings | Metaphor | Philosophy | Thoughts on Art

Underpass
I’ve addressed before the similarities between abstraction and realism from an aesthetic perspective. Technically, no art touted as realistic is truly realistic. It is, simply because it is art, an abstraction of something observed or felt by the artist. The image, which may be a painting, drawing, print, sculpture, or mixed-media representation, my present a convincing likeness of the thing portrayed, but it is only an object made from specific materials. Likewise, a photograph – what many consider the epitome of realism since it “captures” some aspect of reality through mechanical means (and therefore is not subject to subjective interference of the photographer – in short, it doesn’t lie – but any photographer knows otherwise) – is also an abstraction. Neither a painting of a tree nor a photograph of a tree is an actual tree. The tree exists in nature, but the painting and the photograph do not. All three, of course, are objects and do exist in what we call reality. One is a natural object and two are man-made.
I could argue that any painting, regardless of subject matter, is either realistic or abstract, but I would also argue that any painting is both realistic and abstract. The realism of a realistic painting is obvious. The viewer recognizes the image of a flower, a landscape, a person, or whatever the subject that is portrayed in the painting. Where, then, is the realism in a non-objective painting, a painting that does not attempt to represent something recognizable (something that can be observed outside the painting and upon which the painting is based)?
An abstract painting (just like a realistic painting) is a concrete physical object. Aren’t physical objects real? For something to be considered real, does it have to look like something else? An abstract painting is a picture of itself; it represents itself. That self is most often unique and is created from the intention not to be anything except what it is. Being unique and unlike any other image is by no means a handicap nor does it make the image obscure or indecipherable. Nor should anyone feel insulted by it, at a loss, confused, or alienated, that is, unless that is what one chooses to feel.
All art is designed to provoke the audience in certain ways. A viewer/participant can experience the work intellectually, emotionally, or some combination of the two, which could lead to a simple rejection because “I don’t like it” or to some profound realization about the self, the world, or the universe – and there could be an infinite range of responses in between. There is no right or wrong about the outcome, but there can be disagreement or agreement among viewers based on any number of intellectual or feeling responses. A realistic painting can lift one spiritually in a way that the original subject might not. It is the abstractness of that painting that generates that response. The painter saw or felt something and was able to channel that, to communicate that through the medium of paint. Similarly, an abstract painting does essentially the same thing by representing a feeling or emotion that the viewer connects with in a visual and emotional way.
Realism and abstraction are simply terms that designate one aspect of two different kinds of painting. They exist as categories to help understand something about these kinds of art. As with anything complex that we may encounter in the world, we create categories to help us understand and to make sense of things. We often find, however, that categories are not as rigid as we may think at first. The more information we gather, we may begin to refine our understanding of categories, and we also find that observed similarities may blur the edges of those categories. We make a shift in perception. One shift could be that realism and abstraction are not so different.
Leave a Comment