Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

The Collaged Moment


            Every year I enjoy finding interesting presents for those on my giving list. I also enjoy gifting myself, and last year was no exception. I found an interesting video about Robert Motherwell and the New York School of abstract painters that is a good overview of how the so-called abstract expressionists with Motherwell as their spokesperson eventually became successful as artists and shifted the direction of American painting in the twentieth century. Today I reviewed portions of the video and was particularly interested in the discussion of how Motherwell and a few others began using collage as an experimental form of expression. Motherwell was the main one of this group to continue utilizing collage throughout his career.

            Collage as an art form is credited to Picasso and his early cubist work. When he and Georges Braque were creating Cubism in the early 1900s, Picasso applied rope, paper, pieces of wood and other items to paintings instead of painting images of them. Braque picked up on the idea very quickly to give a sense of immediacy and a new kind of reality to paintings that, though they were abstract, retained semblance to the observed world. Both painters began with observed reality but translated observations into planar forms that were flattened, cut apart, and reassembled into complex designs that suggested multiple points of view within a single painting. Perhaps the metaphorical idea of cutting images apart influenced the introduction of cut and torn shapes (paper, wood, etc.) into works, or maybe the joining of real objects with painted ones was commentary on the repurposing of images that has always been the unstated basis of painting. Perhaps collaged elements were tongue-in-cheek inclusions to add levity to the serious redefinition of forms.

            I’m not so interested in tracing the development of collage use in modern painting and its evolution into assemblage and the eventual erasure of the line between painting and sculpture (or at the least questioning the separation of the two, Rauschenberg’s combine paintings as one example) – that development is an interesting journey that includes all the major forms of modern art expression – here I’m interested in the idea of collage as a formal abstract expression using very concrete elements. Motherwwell, in particular, employed collaged elements that were also autobiographical: envelopes from letters received, cigarette packages from cigarettes that he smoked, portions of abandoned drawings or paintings, post cards from places visited, and other items. Rather than using these elements to create a personal narrative, however, he chose items for their color, texture, malleability, and usefulness as design elements. Every choice an artist makes is personal, and to include items with personal history is a comment, intentional or not, on the very idea of choice. Removed from their original purpose, like Picasso’s rope, the collaged elements are abstracted from reality and incorporated into the new reality of the painting.

            Narrative has been at the core of art for millennia and is found in some of the earliest cave paintings depicting hunts. Later it serves to depict important battles or other accomplishments of rulers and often takes on a spiritual purpose that shows the relationship between man and creator. Narrative is so basic to human expression that it is rarely questioned as legitimate artistic expression. Abstraction, however, seems unnatural, counterintuitive, and jarring to many observers. There is no narrative thread to control what appears in abstract work. An abstract artist might counter that abstraction is more direct since it deals with emotional impact, the truth of the moment, so to speak.

            Consider, though, what occurs in everyday experience. Each of us creates a continuous personal narrative that is the story of our lives moment to moment. Whatever we experience, good or bad, becomes part of that narrative. What I find interesting is that though we make the narrative continuous, it actually is anything but. I assume that others experience what I do – one moment I am conscious of present time, the next moment I can be thirty years in the past, and the next moment I may think about what I’m supposed to do next week. I interpret all this within the larger framework of my life and categorize present, past, or future just as I do with language and the use of verbs. These little flashes of consciousness are, however, a lot like collaged thoughts arranged within that larger narrative. Each memory or each perception is a kind of abstraction of the larger whole. Maybe the whole is an abstraction built from each momentary perception. Either way I conclude a sense of reality – what I call my personal reality that more or less coincides with other people’s perceptions of their realities and what together we call our collective reality that is verified moment to moment in news feeds from a variety of media. Reality is an abstraction. It is a collection of thoughts and feelings extracted from perceptions, themselves abstractions from physical sensations.

            Think of a piece of music, for example, to which there is a strong emotional response. I can think of many. I don’t question that music; I simply enjoy its beauty and its power to move me emotionally. I might learn things about the composer and his or her experience that gives me another way of perceiving that piece and perhaps even enhances my initial response. I may think of other music from similar time or a different period that also impacts me emotionally. With more of these experiences, I may build a way of thinking about both my personal experience and the kind of music that relates to other experiences that have nothing to do with music. Music is abstract, for it is just sound organized rhythmically, tonally, and harmonically that creates an emotional response in the listener, and the emotional response can become intellectual as well. The experience of painting, especially abstract painting, is like a visual equivalent to the experience of music. Every moment in time is a collage of possibilities given shape by the sensibility of the individual who senses them. Art is the outward expression of those possibilities.

 

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post