Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Schemers and Dreamers


            I heard a short interview this morning on NPR with Jamie Bernstein, Leonard Bernstein’s daughter. Among other things, she talked about her father’s engagement with society (and politics) rather than being the aloof, reclusive creative artist living and working in an ivory studio. She called him the grandfather of activist artists. Many artists of the past have been noted for either being politically/socially engaged or disengaged. Seen as artists, their work stands on its own, but seen as human beings, they may be judged differently. Emile Zola took on the French government and establishment with his famous “J’accuse” when he confronted the rampant anti-Semitism over the Dreyfus affair. His long time avant-garde painter but arch conservative (and likely anti-Semite) friend Paul Cézanne broke with him over this issue. I love Cézanne’s work and that of Degas as well, but both men’s racist views are despicable. I greatly admire the work and achievement of Picasso including his resistance to the Nazis during the Second World War, but I find his treatment (mistreatment) of women abhorrent. He doesn’t get a pass because of his artistic genius.

            Throughout recorded human history, art has been politicized by the state, whether secular or religious, for the purpose of propaganda in the service of extension of power. For most of that history, the individual artist was largely anonymous and served the whims of those who wielded power. The real world was controlled by the powerful, and there was little concept of an idealistic way of being. Morality was defined by and imposed by authoritarian rule. Gradually, though, new ideas emerged beginning with the Greeks, and a fledgling sense of democracy came into being. It would be many centuries into the future before equality was an essential issue. Interestingly, though, a new sense of beauty developed placing an idealized human form at the center of that perception. Art had a new potential purpose that was not necessarily aligned with the state. It could lead to subversive expression.

            During the Enlightenment period of the eighteenth century, thinkers and leaders still looked back to Classical Greece for inspiration both artistically and politically but moved philosophically towards reason and rationalism applied to scientific, religious, and social practices. The French Revolution and the American Revolution established new principles of equality and an ideal social order in keeping with Christian belief of individual importance (equality in the eyes of God). This shift in thinking should have eliminated discrimination, slavery, corruption, and greed since all of these are counter to democratic impartiality and spiritual oneness. Humans, however, tend to alter the most inclusive beliefs into something self-serving. During this time, art expressed the spiritual (mostly Christian in the West) and the secular with an emphasis on morality as seen in Neo-Classicism and later Romanticism. All of this (this being a very simplified summary) had enormous implications for the modern period beginning about the middle of the nineteenth century.

            Someone once said that you can’t see where you’re going without knowing where you’ve been. Unfortunately, this idea is lost on many people today who know little or nothing about the past. For example, in my country we have a current political administration that cares little for art, for history, or for the core principles upon which our nation was founded despite its bluster to the contrary. Even many religious beliefs have been reduced to a rigid fundamentalism that is more restrictive than inclusive. They seem to forget that this country would not exist without European alliances (France and France’s Spanish and Dutch allies) that enabled a relatively weak band of colonies to prevail over an international power. One question then, were does art fit today in this landscape of schemers and dreamers?

 

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post