Blog
Metaphorical
Posted on 3/9/2021 2:38:26 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art and Psychology | Art in Life | Learning about Art | Life Experience | Metaphor | Philosophy | Spirituality | Thoughts on Art | Writing

In the Cathedral
The concept of art is bandied about quite frequently, and many profess to know its secrets while many others are completely perplexed by its meaning. A great many more are simply indifferent, for it seems to touch nothing in their lives, or would not seem so if they gave it any thought whatsoever. Yet art has lasted longer than any other man-made creation save for the most rudimentary of shaped tools. Even those tools, however, may not predate some forms of art scratched on rocks or the sides of caves. What is it though that makes marks or scratches or smeared pigment into this thing called art?
Representational painting – a painting that actually looks like something one can see in the world – is most readily identifiable as art by the greatest number of people. The more detailed that object is rendered, the more lifelike it appears, the more comfortable the majority of observers will feel in its presence. In short, they can identify the subject of the rendering and judge it ‘good’ by its verisimilitude. Many times have I heard the comment, “It looks like a photograph,” as though this were the highest praise. I would suggest, however, that unless something else happens, that verisimilitude has simply created an excellent illustration rather than a work of art.
In her book of essays, Metaphor & Memory, Cynthia Ozick refers to a statement attributed to Picasso, “Any man can make the sun into a yellow ball. Ah, but to make a yellow ball into the sun!” A bit of unpacking reveals levels of truth that require some imaginative perception, which I believe is the very thing that art teaches us the most. First, children will depict a sunny day by painting or drawing a large round yellow ball to represent the sun. Their depiction relies on the simplest and easiest understood color and shape that to the child’s mind captures what the sun appears to be, a round yellow disc hovering in the sky. They might even add yellow lines radiating outward from the disc to suggest that the disc is projecting light from its surface. The childish rendering is a symbolic image like others found in ancient scrolls, on temple walls, on rock surfaces, or in a variety of primitive interpretations. The intent in all of these is to graphically show what the sun is understood to be by creating an image any viewer will associate with it. A rudimentary metaphor has been created.
The second part of Picasso’s statement suggests something more complex and mysterious, a kind of transformation where a painted image appears to glow so that the viewer senses radiance, illumination, possibly even heat from something that an artist created that has none of these physical properties. The imagination of the viewer has been activated by the imaginative vision of the artist. The image of the sun has moved beyond symbol where the viewer’s experience isn’t limited to the idea of sun but also incorporates sensations and emotions and associations with prior experiences, memories, and ideas – the viewer has moved to the realm of metaphor. For me, this brings to mind lines from Wallace Stevens, “Things as they are/ Are changed upon the blue guitar.” Art, through metaphor (whether written, painted, sung, played, danced) invites its audience to a place outside of time and space while being experienced in the specific time and space of the art itself. It is as if a magical door, perhaps a looking glass, has whisked the willing to a place of enlightened play, creative revery, and imaginative contemplation.
Leave a Comment