Blog
Random Thoughts
Posted on 10/6/2010 5:06:59 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Thoughts on Art
What is truth in life experience? Is it only the factual reporting of specific events – no embellishment, no exaggeration, no interpretation? Or, is truth the meaning that the experiencer gives to the circumstance? In the Life of Pi, Yann Martel creates a marvelously engaging if far-fetched story of a shipwrecked boy and a tiger together on a lifeboat. The narrative is so descriptive and detailed that it becomes believable, perhaps until the encounter with the floating island. The bounds of truth seem stretched to breaking, yet the landscape – even though bizarre – takes on a credibility that defies reason. Later, when the entire survival story is recounted to clerks from the company that owns the lost ship, they do not believe the tale filled with wild animals and a carnivorous island. The character, Pi, then spins a tale of deprivation and delirium minus the animals that because of its savagery is ultimately rejected by the clerks. But which, if either, might be the true tale? The question of belief – reality, spirituality, God – is the real question. What do we, each of us, regard as truth? What is the truth of our own existence? What do our stories, myths, and legends reveal about who we are? Don’t we often – aren’t we often – tempted to believe?
For many years there has been debate between art and science from one perspective or between religion and science from another. Science, supposedly, derives from observation and inquiry, and offers proof based on these. Art often expresses the heart, the inexpressible and unknowable, and through symbol and metaphor makes these things manifest (or at least understandable). Yet the paradoxical questions of existence that are addressed in art are answered only with ambiguity. Something seems to represent something else. Something stands for something else and that idea appeals to our senses of both emotion and logic. Recent scientific theory, despite its rigorous intellectual exercise, appears to lead us to more ambiguity and more metaphor. Light exists as a particle and a wave and can exhibit both qualities simultaneously. String theory metaphorically describes an understanding of reality. Multiple universes coexist. Time is flexible and space immeasurable.
Artistic expression has become so fragmented that it is necessary to identify specifically the type of art being discussed. Realism, for example, has a long tradition in the history of painting. Yet historically realism has manifested in radically different schools of thought and depiction. Compare Renaissance painting with Classicism or Romanticism or Impressionism or Expressionism or Photo-realism. An artist claiming to be a realist painter could fall into any one of these categories or inhabit some hybrid form that combines elements of two or more of these. A viewer might reject an impressionistic painting as too sketchy and gravitate to a painting that looks more like a photograph – in other words, choose clarity and order over evanescence. A painter may approach a painting by first creating a solid, well-defined drawing and further develop that with color to strengthen the illusion of painted reality. Another painter may observe patches of light and dark, bits of color, and by arranging colored strokes proximal to each other ‘allow’ an image to emerge. The two painters may or may not arrive at the same place given each one’s comfort level with finish (rough or polished).
That we observe the world around us is a given. How carefully we observe and for what purpose obviously impact the result of the observation. How we, as painters, make use of our observations will depend on personality, experience, training, understanding, bias, and imagination. How marvelous that artistic expression allows for so much diversity.
Leave a Comment