Blog
An Appreciation
Posted on 2/20/2011 6:01:11 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

"Nanny and Child" by Eva Gonzales
Yesterday my wife and I attended a members’ preview of Impressionist paintings on loan from the National Gallery opening today at the Museum of Fine Arts Houston. All of these works, roughly 50 paintings, I have seen numerous times on previous visits to the National Gallery. This time, however, I was particularly struck by one painting over all the other magnificent examples on view. Perhaps the recent blog by Brian Sherwin that discusses sexism and other negative isms within the art world lingered somewhat in my mind.
The painting that stood out for me (and my wife) is Eva Gonzales’ Nanny and Child. The 26” by 32” (approx.) canvas was painted over 1877 to 1878. Supposedly it is based on Eduoard Manet’s The Railway of 1873, which is also in the exhibition. Wisely, the curators did not hang the paintings together or even in the same room. One would surely have distracted from the other. Gonzales’ painting, though slightly smaller than Manet’s, is in many ways far more interesting and engaging.
Eva Gonzales was the only official student of Manet, and like him she did not exhibit with the Impressionists during her lifetime. As her work matured, however, she developed stylistically more in common with the Impressionists than with her mentor. To say that her painting, which contains elements similar to Manet’s, is a softer and more accessible work than his says more, I think, about her painterly concerns than that one is done by a woman and the other by a man. Neither is there a master-student contrast or even rivalry at work in the two paintings. Manet’s painting pre-dates that of his student by nearly five years. She, though, only takes certain elements from her teacher’s composition; there is no attempt whatsoever to copy, interpret, or repaint what he did.
Both paintings show a woman and child in an outdoor setting, the woman facing outward and the child facing away. The child in both paintings holds on to a railing of sorts: in Manet’s picture the child grasps the bars of a fence that separates the two figures from the rest of the scene; Gonzales’ child holds the cross bars of an open gate that swings into the picture space. The gateway, however, is blocked by the child, the seated nanny, and her open umbrella. Manet’s broad areas of color and limited modeling of the figures rankled critics and perplexed viewers. Only a sleeping puppy in the woman’s lap gives the painting any hint of sentiment. The deeper space, areas of dappled sunlight, and wonderful circular movement within the composition of Gonzales’ painting allow the viewer permission to be within the space and visually move through it.
Though it might be tempting for some to interpret these paintings from a sexist point of view, that would be a great disservice especially to Eva Gonzales. She, in fact, created a masterful work at the age of twenty-eight. What a terrible loss to the history of painting that she died in childbirth only six years later. For this one painting to make such a strong statement among the likes of Manet, Monet, Pissarro, Van Gogh, and others included in this exhibition, any viewer would be foolish indeed to diminish a painter based on sex, age, or any criteria other than the work itself. I know I’m not the only one who thinks this: today’s “Zest” section of the Houston Chronicle used Eva Gonzales’ painting on its cover.
Leave a Comment