Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Compulsion or Choice

Posted on 3/14/2011 9:56:07 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Thoughts on Art 

St. Mary's Glacier
St. Mary's Glacier

            Recently I’ve read a number of blogs about why artists do what they do. As would be expected from those who express themselves visually in such varied ways, there also are many expressions of why one does this thing called art. Basically, though, these boil down to two reasons: one feels compelled to make art or one chooses to make art. Which side do you fall on, and does it really matter? If art is the outcome, maybe the motivation matters only to the individual concerned.

            Psychologically, compulsions are often attributed to some sort of disorder. Something is missing and must be satisfied, what psychologists label compensation. Or, because of a deep seated need – emotional, chemical, or physical – the behavior seeks to provide wholeness. This tends to suggest an unconscious process that bypasses the ego and therefore any question of conscious action.

            There are many processes within the body that are unconscious and automatic: breathing, the pumping action of the heart, and the reaction to pain, to name a few obvious ones. I doubt that artists who say they feel compelled to make art would lump that creative action with these autonomic responses of the body. These artists, I feel sure, would still claim to actively shape their artistic experiences rather than submit to unconscious creation like the automatic writing of the surrealist writers (who often edited their creations afterwards anyway). Some art may spring full blown from an artist’s unconscious like a rising Venus, but most art, especially the really good art, comes through the blending of inspiration with old fashioned perspiration.

            After a specific time without food or water, the body will shut down and a person dies. The artistic personality may feel deprived if not allowed to create, but it is doubtful that one would die, at least not directly, from this deprivation. I suspect, though, if an artist were not allowed to create as usual, that he or she would find another way to express that creative energy, perhaps even develop a new form of art. Such is the ingenuity of artists as well as the strength of their desire to create. However, I wouldn’t call desire, no matter how strong, the same as compulsion. So, perhaps if the artist who says he feels compelled to create is giving way to hyperbole, he may really mean he has a strong desire to create, which I believe to be an altogether different experience.

            Other artists may say that there is nothing they want to do except make art. I do think this is basically the same as choosing to do art. Though our bodies may function as biological machines, we as conscious creatures have the power to choose our actions. Unless we abdicate that power through unconscious choice or by malfunction, we create our experience on a daily basis. Choosing to make art and to express one’s self artistically is a powerful affirmation of creative life force. What one does with that energy expressed through individual sensitivity testifies to the great variety of life itself.


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post