Blog
A White House or a Pan of Milk?
Posted on 4/20/2011 8:25:55 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Fannin Street Flowers
Many years ago while still an art student, which is to say before I became a student of art, I was hard at work in the communal studio. Another student came in and sat watching as I painted. He didn’t say much at first, but I could tell something was on his mind. We weren’t particularly friends as he was known for being argumentative, sometimes to the point of being disagreeable and annoying. Maybe if I just kept painting, he’d make his observations and leave.
Soon he began to question why I used a particular color. I answered because the surrounding colors called for that. He said that it didn’t matter what surrounded it – I could choose any color I wanted. Ah – now I knew he’d just come from a discussion with one of the instructors who always emphasized the relativity of color. I felt sure the student had been chastised for his arbitrary color choices. Now he thought he could regain some sense of self by bullying another student.
He began to expound on one of his two favorite topics: color is arbitrary. He meant that color choice should be based more on personal feeling than observation. His second theory was that the study of drawing was a waste of time for modern art students. Abstraction, assemblage, collage, constructions, reproductive techniques, mechanical aids, and other technical innovations made the pursuit of drawing pointless. With respect to color, though, he was convinced that all the color theorists were wrong. The real power of color lay in its random application and not in color harmonies, the effect of light on color, or the effect of one color on another (except by contrast).
I have an argumentative streak myself, but I let him talk, thinking, I suppose, that I’d catch him in some obvious inconsistency and shut him up. I should have known better, but I was still young. Once he said that it made no difference what color surrounded another, the surrounded color would not be changed in any way, I knew I had my chance.
“So you’re saying that if I surround a red with orange that same red will still look the same if I then surround it with green or blue or white?” I asked.
“Won’t matter,” he said. “It could be in the middle of a blue pond or a pan of milk, and it’s still the same red.”
“Technically it’s the same red – we haven’t changed the red. But it will look different to the eye if we change the colored ground,” I asserted.
“Nope. Makes no difference. Still the same red.”
“Are you familiar with the work of Joseph Albers?”
“Sure. Paints squares and stuff.”
“He demonstrates the relativity of color. We can make a warm color appear cool or a cool color warm by changing the ground against which it’s seen. His paintings are all about color influences.”
“Color only changes when you mix something with it.”
I happened to have Alber’s book on color in my backpack. I opened to the plates showing how one color can be made to look different by changing the background color. The effects were startlingly clear.
“Look the same to me,” he said.
It then occurred to me that he was probably color blind. He really couldn’t see shifts in color appearance, so it would make no difference what I argued or tried to demonstrate. He simply wouldn’t get it. All that bluster and argument on his part were just diversions.
Thankfully, in the ensuing years, I haven’t had to deal with colorblind students, but I have encountered many that had never noticed the effect of one color on another. Simple demonstrations of warm against cool or light against dark would begin them on a path of discovery that would help them in their own painting as well as their appreciation of paintings by others. Learning to observe color is a major step but only one step in the process of becoming a painter.
Leave a Comment