Blog
All Is Illusion
Posted on 9/13/2011 6:18:23 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The Dove
During the fifties and sixties much was argued about the nature of painting. Many painters eliminated imagery from their work by stressing that a painting is solely the manipulation of paint on a flat surface. Illusionistic space is nothing more than illusion, and, in fact, a lie. Some artists removed texture, some removed any suggestion of the artist’s hand at work, some allowed the paint to soak into the surface rather than lie atop it, the scale of works grew beyond the easel and migrated to floors and walls eventually becoming environments, each artist reaching more and more for that elusive truth as only artistic expression could state it. The reductive theoretical spins that abounded each tried to undercut the other. Sculpture became squares and cubes and ultimately, process. Dance became stationary postures. Music became silence between fewer and fewer sounds. Often the result was to alienate the already alienated artist from his or her audience and even from his or her own experience. Still, there was an impulse to make, to do, and to experience through art some element of truth or beauty, though these words might be substituted with words like process, immediacy, environment, or some other techno-jargon that attempted to promote inclusion while denying personal expression. All of this was taking place, of course, as the artist promoted himself or herself shamelessly as the next greatest visionary.
The great religions have all taught that everything is illusion, except, perhaps, the religious experience itself, although that can be seductive and misleading as well. If we think of religion as a way to understand, as a way to discover meaning in existence, as a way to verbalize or come to terms with the experience of aliveness, as a way to connect with the larger context (beyond the self), then isn’t religion another form of artistic expression? Aren’t illusion and truth and beauty all part of the same package?
It’s an illusion that stars twinkle in the night sky. We’ve proven that the atmosphere ‘makes’ the stars seem to dance their light. It is an illusion that some stars even shine at all since they are so far away and it takes so many light years for the light to reach us, those stars no longer exist. Their ghost light may shine on for many generations, but, in truth, they have already disappeared. What does it matter if a painting has the appearance of depth or is totally flat, if it depicts an image of something recognizable or if it is merely its own image? Neither is any more real than the other. Both contain metaphorical content that exists in the realm of imagination, not unlike the star that shines even though it is non-existent. We perceive what we think we know and trust that perception as truth about the world around us. The record that is painted or carved into artistic form is one person’s expression of a truth that may be illusion or an illusion that may be truth.
Leave a Comment