Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

A Picture or a Painting?

Posted on 10/3/2011 7:05:38 PM
By Donald Fox
7 Comments

Dorothy's Stump
Dorothy's Stump

            Although the ideas expressed in this post could apply to most any painting, abstract or realistic, I’m limiting consideration to realistic painting only. This will allow me the opportunity to discuss image as something recognizable as well as feeling and emotional response. Often I am attracted to a particular scene because of a variety of factors. The observed colors, interplay of light and shadow, interaction of shapes and forms, or the position of objects in space may singly or together be elements that capture my attention. There is no right or wrong about this, neither is there accounting, except in particular instances, for how one set of stimuli may hold sway and another not.

            Plein air artists frequently talk about the joy of painting in front of the subject. There is something magical about the experience as one attempts to set down in fairly rapid order observed notations that result in some verisimilitude to the given subject. Brush strokes and color choices are key elements in reproducing the observed phenomenon. Is the complete painting, though, now dependent on the source or only itself as an object of perusal? Has the artist given the viewer primarily a picture of something or created a new object to experience that has little to do with the thing originally seen? Obviously, if a person walks into a museum, gallery, or studio, the only visible object is the painting. The landscape is nowhere to be seen. There is nothing to compare the painting with save itself or some other nearby painting. The viewer may have a memory of some similar landscape or setting, and that experience may affect how the viewer responds to the painting. But, does that memory have anything to do with the painting itself? No, I would say it only has to do with the viewer’s experience and how he or she connects that experience to the painting. This becomes an added dimension on the part of the viewer that the painter may anticipate but is of little consequence to him as creator.

            An artist looking at someone else’s work might reflect on other paintings done or seen or upon his/her own personal experiences. This would be natural enough to expect. However, for most artists, first and foremost, what he/she considers is the painting itself. Careful observation of the brushstrokes, the color choices, the various design elements, in short, those things that the original painter considered when making the painting are in the mind of the artist-observer. As observer, I might question whether the artist was successful in his attempt – not so much in capturing the scene, for I have not actually seen that – but has the artist given me something interesting and affecting to observe. Am I moved by the painting as I observe it as the artist was probably moved by the scene as he painted it? It is the painting, not the scene, that is the point of connection. The painting could just as well be abstract and represent nothing but an emotional response to color and design.

            Do these questions make any difference to the overall experience of the work? Certainly anyone is free to respond to an artwork in any way they may choose. I would argue, though, through my bias as a painter, that an observer is missing a great deal if all that he or she can see is the object that is portrayed. In other words, the picture is more important than the painting to him or her. If the only criterion of judgment is how well the image is depicted (how much does it look like whatever it is), then a great deal is lost in the experience. As a painter, then, I see part of my job as nudging the viewer to see something besides the image. If I can do that, I have done more than simply satisfy myself by the process of painting.


Comments

7 Responses to A Picture or a Painting?

Hi Donald.

I think you make some excellent points in this post ie regarding picture or a painting.

Hello Donald,

I dare say you have stepped directly into a conversation that has been taking place since antiquity. Aristotle and Plato were among the first to speculate on the value of art being merely a simulacra or containing something greater within it that goes beyond the imitation. Down the road Tolstoy took up the challenge and discussed the notion of true art as needing to convey emotion.

At the heart of the discussion lies beauty. I'm not talking about pretty, but rather that which is truly possessing the qualities of the beautiful. It seems that if one is simply trying to duplicate nature, which is inherently beautiful (that is good unto itself), then one will forever fail. If on the other hand, one reaches for conveying an aspect of the human spirit within their duplication, then it is more likely that the artwork itself will resonate with the qualities of the beautiful, and thus enable the viewer to have an equally powerful response as the artist when the work was created.

This is a rich topic that can be discussed on many levels and certainly cannot be fully dissected with one blog response, but I am so glad you brought it up. It is a vital question that all artists should ponder.

Bruce.

Hi Donald, I agree with your premise and personally keep trying to improve the creative content of my work, without relying on slick tricks to appear artier to those who aren't aware of the finer points of composition, color theory and draftsmanship.
While I do agree with the above I must say that, from what I see in the business world of art, the subject and sentimental titles DO have a great influence on the sale of many pieces, not that we real painters ever let that influence our work (h-m-m-m?).
So, for we painters who do not paint for the gallery's; and who see the difference between superficial and serious painting, separating real art from mere pictures; we must strive to be pure and professional...but, to me, and this is the important part; we must always remember that we too are human and a little beauty for beauty's sake and a little sentiment to warm the cockles of our hearts will keep our art, ART, and not a correct formula for perfection.

Thanks for your comment, Dave. I'm curious which points you were attracted to.

Bruce - you mentioned beauty. There is the other discussion about beauty and truth (Keats' famous line, "beauty is truth, truth beauty..."). That can certainly overlap with the argument about mimesis. I expect most artists consider these questions whether they verbalize them or not. I like to return to them often as I expect you do, and, yes, there is a lot of literature devoted to the subject(s). BTW - there are several other blogs you might enjoy - Is It Beautiful? 1/19 and What Does It Mean? 1/16. Thanks for commenting.

Hi Donald:
I was reading your Blog when one of my son's brought up a ?. They ask me how do I come up with the ideas for my Paintings that I do? the reason they ask at this time is, the one I just finished is a scene with snow covered houses and mountain. Didyou get it from a photo NO. I tell them that I can not say were the ideas come from. What I can say, is that some were in my mind I see what I put on canvas or paper,the places the time and the colors, I honestly can say that ,the ideas come out of my head ,the colors are from what I see at the time that I start to paint. I don't even know if I have a technique because I just started Art in Oct of 2010. I see what your saying I think? the pitcher is not what you want to see ,you want the viewer to look deep into the art work and see the beauty that the artist put there for their enjoyment, and to help the person have a relation with the Art work, or the place that they are viewing in the back of their minds. When I look at art I see the beauty that the painter put out there for me. I try not to judge the artist by what he or she has given me to enjoy some more than others but still it is the viewer that has the last thoughts. I hope that I have not confused the Blog,any way I THOUHGT THAT IS WAS GREAT THANK YOU.

Der Mr Fox,

What makes one style of art better over another?

This question, when asked will set in motion a never ending debate, and that is because art is suggestive.
Is a painting a better painting because it comes from the heart but is technically weak?
I photorealism bad art because it depicts objects as seen but it has a higher technical level? The answer to this question will change from person to person and their taste.

Is impressionism better art than realism because it depicts an impression of what the artist is seeing? My answer to that is, no! Both of them have their own merit!

I disagree that art that is appreciated for the beauty and reality of how the image was depicted has less emotion than one that is an interpretation of that object
If you choose to do other wise is your personal style, and style is what makes us artist different!

Thanks, John for your comments. I'm not sure I agree that the viewer has the last thought - the viewer certainly has his/her thoughts, but I still think about paintings that I made thirty years ago. Whatever I have put into a painting will stay there however someone else might see it.

Jorge, I'm not sure what you're responding to. I did not talk about style or say that one kind of painting is better than another. Neither did I say that particular kinds of painting have less emotion than others. My main point is that, in my opinion, if a painting is viewed simply as a picture of something, the viewer is missing a large part of the artistic experience which also has to do with interpretation and expression.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post