Blog
General or Particular
Posted on 1/13/2012 8:03:51 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Merced River
Aside from being judged by the eloquence of their prose and originality of their ideas, writers are considered believable and trustworthy by the amount of detail they include. Vagueness in writing does not create effective communication with the reader. Descriptive details help the reader understand the writer’s message. For example, a writer may say he or she was greatly affected by the death of a parent, but if little else is said, the reader doesn’t know how the writer was affected. If, however, the writer includes that he was only five years old when his father died from a hereditary disease and the likelihood of the same happening to him as an adult is statistically high, say 85%, the reader knows more about the writer’s possible feelings. The writer may continue with details of a childhood without a father. Later there may be musings on living with a possible early death sentence including concerns about having a family and passing on the potential for early death to his children.
As humans we have many higher mental functions that separate us from our fellow animal inhabitants of earth. We think and plan and scheme. We consider our past and project into the future. We also have this marvelous capacity to conceptualize in imaginative ways about our lives and the world in which we live. We can generalize from particular experiences to create a broader understanding of events, or we can take a broad concept and break it into its detailed parts. This ability to think in general terms or specific terms is a major part of what artists do as they create art. Painters, for example, often begin a painting with a rough drawing of large shapes in order to organize the picture space and locate various parts within that space. Color is blocked in, again in the most general way, to create an underpainting, to establish a basic color scheme, and to begin the process of harmonizing the various design elements.
One obvious way to think of the painting process is as movement from the general to the specific. An artist may utilize all or some of the ways that contrast is created – dark and light, warm and cool, bright and dull, large and small, round or angular, and so on – in order to make the painting more clearly defined. Detail comes from contrast, from one thing being clearly seen against something else. For the visual artist, though, this isn’t simply about adding more details. Very definite choices are being made about what to include and what to leave out. In a sense the artist is editing as the painting progresses.
The average viewer tends to think of a photograph as the most true to life representation of a person or place. Most any photographer can give an extensive lecture on the limitations of photography. The tendency for the camera to overstate or understate lighting, which affects clarity of the image, the fact that focus is sharpest within a relatively narrow distance range depending on camera settings, or that straight lines in the periphery appear to be bent or curved by the lens, are just a few of the optical problems photographers face. A photographer also cannot move fixed objects to create a better composition.
Sometimes, of course, photographs appear to be sharply focused and filled with details. This may be important for identification purposes, but identification is generally a small part of what artists consider. There is usually much more interest in mood, emotional impact, ambiance, color interaction, making a visual statement about the subject, and other factors. Many artists, in fact, will cringe if someone says in the most complimentary way that the painting looks like a photograph.
For the artist, details are important as accents. They bring the viewer’s attention to a specific area of the painting but then allow it to move on to another area of interest. Artists orchestrate their paintings to achieve their desired results. The success or failure will depend on the skill and experience of the painter. If the artist is only interested in portraying detail, however, it is not likely that the painting will be a successful one.
Leave a Comment