Blog
Visual Lie or Perceived Truth?
Posted on 1/24/2012 4:44:52 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

What does it mean for a painter to present an image in the most realistic manner? What is realism anyway? Is a many times over life sized head painted by Chuck Close in the 70s with painstaking detail actually realism? Is Titian considered more of a realist than Leonardo da Vinci? What about Rembrandt or Velasquez or Courbet or Manet? Is there such a thing as objectivity in realistic painting?
I’d suggest that no matter how intently he may observe a scene, object, or person, the painter creates a fiction according to the subjective decisions made while executing the painting. The art may be based on reality, but whatever so-called realism is produced is only a semblance of what was observed. This idea that art is not reality has been debated at least since the time of Plato and Aristotle, yet for several thousand years painters have been attempting to “capture” aspects of reality on paper, canvas, and other substrates. There is a definite fascination with this reconstruction of things observed.
Photographers also observe through the camera lens, but despite a layman’s claim to the contrary, a photograph is no more realistic than a painting. Laurie Fendrich, a painter, noted in a recent blog: “All photography begins by manipulation; philosophically speaking, photographic images are as removed from the “truth” of the 3-dimensional world as the paintings made by painters. The painter’s art differs from the photographer’s only in relying on a wider range of what to initially select from the infinity of sensations. (Some painters are like Caravaggio, emphasizing light and shadow, others like Michelangelo, stressing sharp outline, and still others like Titian, going for color.)” “The Fall of Photography.” The Chronicle of Higher Education. January 23, 2012.
Many painters, realistic and abstract, talk about truth in their work. Even writers utilize fiction as a means to creating truthful observations about life. William Faulkner’s speech before the Nobel Committee in 1950 stressed the “old verities and truths of the heart” as the subject of artistic expression. Though it may or may not be discussed openly, I believe most artists recognize the limitations of art in representing reality. They also understand the power of art to make statements about reality, life, the world in which we live, how we see, feel, and think through images by compressing experience in very precise ways. The artist selects what is to be perceived by the viewer, reader, observer and redefines it symbolically, metaphorically, psychologically, and emotionally. Through the experience of the art, the viewer is afforded insight into the human condition from the most ordinary of events as microcosm to the macrocosmic grandeur of life at its most expansive. Truth is multilayered and can reside in the smallest observation as well as the grandest theory.
Leave a Comment