Blog
Controlling the Space
Posted on 2/22/2012 8:52:28 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Thoughts on Art

The Reader
Governments have major concerns about controlling space. They control their borders to ensure that uninvited people do not enter against current laws. Controlling the space within their borders includes the air space as well as the ground space and the underground space. Issues related to water rights or mineral rights must be resolved according to whatever legal guidelines are set in place within a particular country. Cities control space for making streets, running sewer lines, power lines, gas lines, and anything else that is necessary for the proper functioning of the municipalities. Some spaces may be kept open as public spaces for everyone to enjoy. Other spaces may be restricted for specific use. Sometimes, though, problems result when there is conflict between public and private, and then some resolution must be created. There is nothing unusual about this.
Artists work to control space in paintings, drawings, designs, sculptures, and in nearly any form of creative endeavor. The issues will vary according to the medium, but it is an area of concern. Recently I came across two very interesting space related problems for two different artists. Both are sculptors, and though the basic problems are quite different, there also is an unusual similarity between them.
In 1989 the Berkeley Art Project group initiated an art monument competition for a work to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Free Speech Movement that began on the UC Berkeley campus. The idea behind this is that once the monument was created, it would be given to the university, which would be in less of a position to refuse something they would not have commissioned themselves. After an open period of feedback from public, art critics and professionals, and some university faculty – a very democratic selection process – Mark Brest van Kemper’s Column of Earth and Air was chosen. The design consisted of a six-inch circle of dirt surrounded by a six-foot circle of concrete around which is inscribed “This soil and the air space extending above it shall not be part of any nation and shall not be subject to any entity’s jurisdiction.” In effect, an invisible sixty thousand foot column of air is the primary monument. Initially, the university did not want to accept the gift. Under public pressure, school officials relented on the condition that any press releases make no mention of the Free Speech Movement, still a sore spot with the university. The irony here is delicious: censorship of a monument to free speech. I also especially love the way the concept of space is cleverly utilized in the sculpture.
The second spatial challenge concerns James Turrell’s 2003 sculpture Tending, (Blue) currently located in the Nasher Sculpture Garden in Dallas, Texas. This site specific sculpture is an enclosed room with a clear opening in the ceiling nine and a half feet square, which leaves the sky visible. Programmed lights in the room shift from red, blue, green, and yellow at set intervals. These create amazing changes in the appearance of the sky. It would seem as though the space is well controlled. However, nearby a forty-two story condo is under construction which will intrude on the view from the room. The primary intent of the artist will have been defeated. The sculpture is temporarily closed to the public while the artist re-thinks the design to remedy the future problem, but obviously his initial concept of controlling space has been compromised.
In many respects painters can control space more easily through composition and color, but, even so, careful planning and execution are necessary to ensure successful results. Once the painting leaves the artist’s possession, however, certain controls are lost. The frame may change, and the lighting conditions under which the painting may be shown are usually beyond the artist’s control. Neither of these may necessarily affect how the artist has handled space within the painting, but he may never know for sure either.
Sources:
“Berkeley’s Invisible Monument to Free Speech.” San Francisco Chronicle (original article). UCIRA Santa Barbara. 2010
Breal, Jordan, “Straight from the Art.” Texas Bound for Family Fun. Texas Monthly supplement. March/April 2012: 15
Leave a Comment