Blog
What's the Source?
Posted on 4/22/2012 7:03:36 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Thoughts on Art

Summer Storm
There is some dialogue today between painters who paint from photographs and those who paint en plein air. This immediately lets out those who paint abstractly since their subject lies within rather than without in the external world. Perhaps some legitimate points can be made in support of either camp, but bottom line, I don’t think there’s much of a fuss to be made.
A painting made from a photograph is, to a large extent, dependent on the quality of the original photograph. Even here, though, a practiced and inventive painter could create a superior image from an inferior one. Assuming that the photo’s composition is good, the light and color are fairly true, and enough detail is visible so that any viewing question might be answered, then the photograph can be a good subject. However, what the painter should be aware of is that photographs tend to flatten images, exaggerate lights and darks, and lose detail in those light and dark areas. So the question arises, how is the photograph actually being used?
If the painter is simply copying verbatim what is seen in the photo, more than likely the ensuing painting will not be a good one no matter how closely it follows the photograph. All the painter will have accomplished is a painted copy. This is little more than paint by numbers; exchanging one set of information (paint) for another (pixels). There is no particular challenge here except to match colors and copy a design.
Painters, in the process of learning how to paint, learn the visual vocabulary of painting. They learn about color: hue, intensity, temperature, and value. They learn about the effect of colored light and atmospheric effects created by distance. They learn to visually edit what they see, to limit detail, to organize space, to adjust color for spatial effects, to modulate edges, to create color harmonies, and to compose within the picture space. These things cannot be learned by copying photographs, but, if a painter understands this vocabulary, he could translate a photograph into a successful painting.
We could almost say the same thing about painting from nature – that one won’t automatically learn the rules of painting just because painting is done outside. Now a new set of problems occur. One, the light is always changing. In thirty minutes a scene can change significantly as shadows shift and objects come into view that previously were in shadow. Also, sunlight can sometimes be harsh, and the glare can make seeing color difficult. Reading lights and darks can be challenging as well. If the painter paints exactly what he sees, the resultant painting would be disorganized and confusing. Again, the experienced painter understands that changes have to be made in a scene in order for it to read correctly as a painting.
An artistic painting, regardless of subject or source, is a translation or interpretation on the part of the painter. He or she is constantly making choices and adjusting what is observed to fit an idea that the painter may not even fully know when the painting is first begun. It is as though the painter discovers the subject and the painting in the process of painting it. For the experienced painter, the principles that govern painting have become ingrained over time. Some choices that are made may be consciously thought out and some choices may be intuitive based on the internalized knowledge. The painting, as it progresses, begins to speak to the painter (in a sense) to show what needs to happen next. If one understands the process, it shouldn’t matter what the source is. What’s really important is how the painter responds.
Leave a Comment