Blog
The Artistic Challenge
Posted on 4/29/2012 6:16:04 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Mallard
In art, religion, and politics, often there is a kind of easy thinking that tends to paint ideas with too broad a brush. It’s a blend of stereotyping, generalizing, and moralizing that does not lead to any satisfactory dialog about the topic; it simply tends to either push people’s buttons or elicit knee jerk supportive response. There is nothing wrong with disagreement on a subject or even a little conflict where blood pressures may rise as one’s opinions are challenged. When there is healthy disagreement – situations where opinions are aired and discourse is invited in the spirit of respect and open inquiry – there is the possibility for growth and mutual understanding.
Cultural issues seem to be the areas where more destructive discourse occurs. So-called “hot button” issues tend to call forth emotional responses first. One feels that his beliefs are being attacked or belittled, one has predetermined that the opponent is closed-minded and judgmental, one is blindingly self-righteous and absolutely knows that the other is dead wrong, or one believes that anyone thinking otherwise than him is evil or worse. These are all emotional commitments that leave no room for reason. Argumentation by definition is a logical presentation of information in order to reach a conclusion. It says nothing about conflict or discord. Emotional attachment to beliefs is something else where an individual has committed allegiance to a concept from learned behavior. It may be sourced from family, culture, race, religion, or brainwashing. Reason never enters the picture. There are many examples of children at some point in their maturation questioning and rejecting their parents’ beliefs only to sometime later returning to the beliefs in a more committed way. They have questioned and then chosen the beliefs rather than simply accepted out of duty.
Sometimes a person may come to a belief after long searching, questioning, reasoning through a number of options, and eventually settling upon a belief that seems the most logical. After a time, there may be a strong emotional bond to this particular belief. If the person remains reasonable, he will recognize at some level that the emotion is self-generated and may even periodically reassess the idea or the commitment. Generally this person will not feel threatened if someone disagrees or offers another perspective. The said individual might even feel excited by discourse on an issue that in his own mind is already settled, for he understands that growth as a human being often comes from challenges to long held notions.
Art is a very broad topic that can encompass many sets of beliefs some of which are mutually exclusive. Often, practitioners speak about art in spiritual terms as though its practice is similar to religious expression. They may say that the purpose of art is to enhance and elevate the experience of life, to add beauty and truth to the world. But, what if they encounter art that deals with some societal taboo related to sex or religion or relationship? That art no doubt would be rejected and either criticized as non-art, as confrontational or sensational, or simply as degenerate and depraved. This would be their choice, but so is it the choice of the artist who made the “offensive” art. There are deeper questions about freedom of expression and freedom of choice that are not easy to resolve. Art has never been only about painting pretty pictures. In the long term, the best art has often been the art that has been the most challenging and the most challenged. Of course there is the other side that can say just because it’s challenging doesn’t make it good art. Artists and viewers alike bear responsibility for being educated and for balancing those human traits of reason and emotion. This is a continuing task that doesn’t simply stop when some level of comfort is achieved.
Leave a Comment