Blog
Is It Real?
Posted on 5/6/2012 9:59:24 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Reflecting Pool
Charles Dickens’ novel A Tale of Two Cities begins with the lines, “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness…” and goes on to become a kind of sociological, political thriller and romance. These lines, though, could easily apply to today’s world of instant access to the broadest range of information, the excesses of materialist culture, and all manner of dissociation from the natural world. I love computers and the internet, for as tools these give me command over more information than I could have accessed in weeks or months utilizing traditional libraries and search methods. However, this convenience comes at a price.
When I was in undergraduate school and later in graduate school, there was no internet and there were no desktop computers. Research was a lengthy process dependent on a good library with thousands of books and back issues of periodicals. Though labor intensive, the process was not altogether without reward. There is something quite special about moving through musty stacks of books spread row after row on level above level in search of few specific items. It’s as though you’re inside what represents a vast collection of knowledge, inside a mind as it were that is a collective of many minds over many centuries. A certain sense of awe and respect for this abundant information seems inherent to its physicality. It was quite a different experience sitting in front of a small machine scrolling through microfiche images of long defunct newspapers. The modern technological shift of information management had already begun just as it had much earlier with the first printing press.
Studying art from projected slides allowed one to cover many styles and many time periods fairly rapidly. The gist of stylistic change could be understood, but the physicality of actual paintings in a museum or gallery would be the verification of any posited theory that one might dream up while only studying slides. Today, of course, we have virtual images just a click away. Again we can get a general idea of a painting, read about its history or about the artist, but we don’t appreciate the painting’s physicality without the actual presence of the work. In a sense we carry around false images and false ideas while lacking the experience of the real thing. I can take a virtual tour of the Sistine Chapel and see views that I would never be able to see within the actual space of the chapel. Do I know this work better than artist of the past who might have stood there and craned their necks upward to view paintings in dim lighting? Or do I know this work better than later artists who may have seen wonderful reproductions in full color published in some fine art book? I can study the virtual images from near or far and zoom in as close for detail as the pixels on the screen will allow. But what do I know of the scale or color or texture? What do I know of the smell of the place or the experience of the space of the chapel itself?
We see wonderfully imagined and projected worlds on screen such as the hanging mountains in James Cameron’s Avatar. Computer generated images are the standard in today’s blockbuster movies. We easily give ourselves over to the visual trickery and even gauge films on their realistic presentation even when we know that the realism we witness is in fact fantasy. But we relish it. The science fiction stories of simulated realities and people being absorbed by fantasy rather than reality have come to pass. We would be very foolish indeed if we denied that what we see on a daily basis graphically portrayed in the news (reality) and what we see outwardly projected in imaginary entertainment affects our thinking and responding to whatever may be left of actual reality. We have woven a false web of connection with which we interface more often in some cases than with the actuality of our experience. We justify our actions by suggesting that we’ve simply expanded our experiential possibilities. In the arts, especially theater, the term suspension of disbelief is used to describe our ability to access the symbolic reality of a play. I’m afraid we all too often suspend our disbelief in areas where there should be the highest engagement, and we end with a very warped perception of the world in which we live that becomes increasingly unrealistic and unreliable. As always, we are at choice in what we do. Let us choose wisely.
Leave a Comment