Blog
You Be the Judge
Posted on 5/31/2012
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Thoughts on Art

Still Life with Random Objects
How do we judge art? and the companion question, What makes good art?, are two of the most important but endlessly debatable questions that anyone could possibly ask. Artists certainly do not agree on this subject; neither do critics, nor academics, nor patrons. It’s tempting and perhaps too easy to resort to clichés, but this would only sidestep the issue. You know the ones: beauty is in the eye of the beholder; one man’s meat is another man’s poison; one man’s trash is another man’s treasure; one man’s pain is another man’s pleasure. Benjamin Franklin wrote in Poor Richard’s Almanack, “Beauty, like supreme dominion/Is but supported by opinion,” and philosopher David Hume said in his Moral and Political that "Beauty in things exists merely in the mind which contemplates them." Both were published in the early 1740s. Essentially both are saying that beauty is subjective – the implication being that disagreement will follow. Hume is also suggesting that things are not inherently beautiful.
In art history, we often find that artists who are popular and successful in their own time are soon forgotten by succeeding generations. The reverse is also true, that artists (the really good ones) are not recognized until after their deaths. This, of course, leads to other clichés about prophets, artists, and prognosticators. What does seem, however, to generate most agreement is the idea that the test of time is the best arbiter of artful taste. If a work is venerated generation after generation, then in all probability it is a genuinely good piece of art. Are we then talking about art by majority rule? If this is the case, what about the tyranny of the majority or its inverse, the tyranny of the minority? We’ve certainly seen these ideas operable relative to social issues. What is culture but a set of principles and subsequent actions by a majority of individuals within a shared space? What appeals to one generation, however, will not necessarily appeal to the next. Compare the 1950s in America to the 1960s. The only thing that bridges the gap is rock and roll music, but even that quickly changes character and color.
The Golden Age of Dutch painting is an interesting period since painting flourished in the presence of newly acquired wealth. Two of the biggest names, Jan Vermeer and Rembrandt van Rijn, have perhaps grown in stature since their demise. Vermeer, whose output was relatively small, was not as successful in his time as many lesser known painters. Rembrandt became very successful and wealthy but also endured horrific familial loss and financial loss. He also lived to see his work go out of style and had great difficulty late in his life selling work or acquiring commissions. Today, however, we acknowledge both of these painters as timeless masters. Are we as humans too fickle in our tastes, are we too influenced by the culture in which we live, are we too narrow minded when it comes to likes and dislikes, or is it possible to transcend our narrow frame of reference and develop interest in work that may be foreign to what we grow up with?
Personally, I vote for an eclectic appreciation. I don’t particularly favor realism over abstraction or any one style over another. I appreciate craftsmanship and refinement, but I might dismiss a finely crafted realistic painting for being too illustrational. Pollock I find less interesting over time, but some of his early abstract/surrealist work is intriguing still. If a piece doesn’t grab me emotionally, it’s not likely I’ll stay with it for long. I know I judge subjectively and probably inconsistently, but I am willing to listen to an argument that may favor something I dislike. I might be convinced. I’ve certainly experienced shifts in my own taste and likely will experience more. In fact, I look forward to it.
Leave a Comment