Blog
Dark and Light and Read All Over
Posted on 6/17/2012 3:01:39 PM
By Donald Fox
2 Comments
Topics: Appreciating Art | Artistic Advice | Learning about Art | Making Paintings | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

Forest Pool
One of the biggest challenges that painting students have with color is working effectively with value. Generally, students can easily grasp the idea of light-dark contrast, but left to their own devices with little guidance they will misread and misuse value more than anything else. This is understandable since colors in themselves are so attractive and sometimes dazzling that it’s easier to think red or blue or green than it is light or dark. When comparative challenges are presented, many students become dazed. Lighter or darker? It’s challenging enough to separate shades of gray – but different colors?
In a design course I took many years ago that focused on color problems, we did numerous exercises in order to understand comparative color. Mostly, we were learning to see, to train our eyes to distinguish gradations of light and dark. We accomplished this in a variety of ways including making color charts. We began simply enough with a three-step scale from white to black to make a light, medium, and dark equally separated in value. Very quickly it became obvious that a 50-50 mixture of black and white don’t make a middle value. Add white to almost any color in equal proportions and the result will not be a middle value.
This seems so elementary as an exercise, but it demonstrates the concept of tinting power – that certain colors are stronger than others (and some obviously weaker). When mixed together one will tend to dominate the mixture. We moved on to five value scales, ten, twelve, twenty. Eventually we made huge color charts with simple gradations by adding white or black, made analogous color mixtures and scales, and cross-mixed with complimentary colors. The seeming drudgery of these exercises was forgotten in the attempt to make equal value steps from light to dark regardless of the number of steps assigned. Sound easy? Give it a try.
The exercise that was most interesting and revealing for me came with interpreting a famous painting of choice. We’d make 8 x 10 or 9 x 12 versions of a particular painting by first interpreting it as a three value study. This requires careful observation and thought to determine the range of each of the light, medium, and dark components. Is a particular area identified as a light or a medium value? Next, we would interpret the same painting using five values. The value selection is greater and creates an image more closely resembling the original painting. Lastly, we would make another interpretation expanded to seven values. As expected, the image is even stronger as more subtlety is revealed by shifting values. Along with each painting, we included the value scale that we used, and we had to be able to match specific values from each scale to those used in the paintings during critique sessions.
When you’re working for a grade in a course, there is specific motivation to do what sometimes may seem to be mundane exercises. The truth is, though, to improve painting skills, anyone can create exercises that focus on specific areas where improvement may be needed. Singers do vocal exercises and drills to keep their voices in shape. Musicians practice difficult passages piecemeal and also in context in order to solve challenges with fingering or interpretation or timing. Painters, too, can work on specific techniques or skills through a wide range of activity that may not always result in a finished painting. The question is, what isn’t working? Next, how can that be improved? Certainly there are many options for moving forward.
2 Responses to Dark and Light and Read All Over
Leave a Comment