Blog
Scholarship and Marketing
Posted on 6/23/2012 8:22:16 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art Business | Art History | Learning about Art | The Working Artist | Thoughts on Art

Happy Isles
There is a lot of difference between scholarship and marketing. Currently in the world of art, a lot of emphasis is placed on sales, creating a brand, and thereby gaining both recognition and financial success. The question of whether particular work is good, unique, or in some way contributes to the larger history of art mat not even be raised. Somewhere in the course of historical events, emphasis has shifted from recognition for particular achievement to recognition based on sales and marketing. This situation seems to have created several schisms within the art community.
In no particular order, for arguments could be made from any side for preeminence, we can identify 1) academic, 2) the New York/major center/international market, 3) popular trends created by savvy marketing, and 4) regional-geographical groups that tend to be small. None of these categories are impenetrable, and sometimes crossover occurs among them.
The academics are generally affiliated with museums and institutions of higher learning. The main goals here are educational and preservational. Scholarship and research on artists, working methods, materials and techniques, and historical trends are the guiding concerns. Artists are studied as part of a specific historical time period, their context in relation to that and also in relation to historical development in a worldwide, often Eurocentric narrative. As a result, a creative hierarchy based on achievement in personal expression rather than financial success is developed. Thus, we can see in this pantheon world recognized and respected artists like Van Gogh, Gauguin, Chardin and others who were not particularly successful in their own time. These artists are mentioned alongside Rubens, Velasquez, or Michelangelo, all of whom enjoyed success for their creative efforts. There may also be many artists who were very successful in their time but are unknown today.
Major art centers like New York or London or Paris tend to produce artists that gain recognition in one location and soon are shared with another. Thus, their reputation and financial success tend to inhabit an international market. The work generally is described as cutting edge or avant-garde – it is often challenging, daring, different by design, and largely inaccessible to a popular audience. Sometimes museums and educational institutions participate in the propagation of these contemporary artists. Pollock, de Kooning, Warhol, and Hirst are examples of this kind of artist.
Popular trends develop around a personality or a particular marketing focus to move an artist from the rarefied air of the museum or art center to widespread popularity. Andy Warhol is an excellent example as are Picasso, Peter Max, or Thomas Kincade. Some may flinch at the mention of the latter two with the former, but we’re only speaking of popular success. Both Warhol and Picasso also participate in the academic and art center worlds whereas Max and Kincade typically do not.
The last category, regionalists, are generally best known within a particular geographical region and may even have significant financial success there. Dalhert Windberg in Texas, Georgia O’Keefe in New Mexico, Claude Howell in North Carolina are a few of these artists. O’Keefe, of course, is the best known and is also part of the academic world of art as well as the art center milieu. She gained widespread popularity for both her desert landscapes and her flower paintings.
These thoughts are by no means complete or definitive. I mention them simply because sometimes discussion regarding marketing suggests that the best art and artists are those who sell the most. Most artists want to be successful, at least to the point of making a decent living from the work they cherish most. Financial success, however, does not necessarily equate with artistic success, i.e. that work is recognized universally as exceptional, unique, and significantly placed within the history of artistic development. Some artists, of course, may not care about that as long as their work sells. This is a personal mindset on the part of each artist, how he or she sees the work in relation to the current market, personal expression and development, and placement within a larger historical context.
Leave a Comment