Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

The Art Question

Posted on 9/2/2012 6:18:27 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art 

Docked
Docked

            The term Art is one that is incredibly broad and multidimensional. In some ways art may be more inclusive than exclusive, and it may or may not require distinction between Art with a capital A (high art, Fine Art) and art with a lowercase a as in popular or low art. We utilize categories to better understand a complex subject, and certainly art would qualify as a subject with great complexity and many parts.

            As an artist, when I speak about art, I use the lowercase term as a matter of convenience, but I’m thinking about Fine Art rather than popular art. The latter in my mind is only art by the loosest of definitions. To speak of Jennifer Lopez, for example, as an artist as she is sometimes referred to in the press, seems a stretch. She is a performer and quite a good one. The same could be said of many singers, dancers, musicians, and other performers.

            There are exceptions, though; performers that by their extraordinary achievement as creators who happen to work in the popular domain, achieve a level of artistry that ranks them as artists of the highest order. Singer-songwriter Paul Simon immediately comes to mind. For decades he has penned songs whose lyrics are consistently high poetry filled with rich imagery, symbolic language, and ambiguity. He addresses subjects that are personal, topical, and that achieve the level of universality that makes art become Art.

            Many people will have favorite performers that they might also argue in favor of elevation to artist status. Granted there is always the subjective in artistic assessments. This has been true for hundreds if not thousands of years. With ancient art we are generally looking at fewer examples and at what are the remnants of a particular culture. Perhaps it was the ancient Greeks who first tackled the question of art and attempted to define it. Prior to that time, other cultures had certain principles and guidelines in place that governed the style of representation. Without some system, there would not be the consistency that is obvious in ancient Sumeria, Egypt, or Persia, but how they defined art, if they did, I don’t know.

            It also becomes somewhat problematic to address the idea of development in realistic representation. Again the Greeks are given credit for moving sculptured figures from the blocked and rigid Egyptian influence of the early kouros and kore figures to the contrapposto figures of the Classical period. There is written evidence that they also achieved an unparalleled realism in painting, but not enough painting survives to verify this. It would be more than 1500 years before naturalistic realism shows up in Renaissance painting in Northern and Southern Europe. This certainly doesn’t mean that there wasn’t art during this interim period.

            But what makes any of that art, art? Great skill and consistency are exhibited in ancient Egyptian sculpture and in painting. Creative imagination is also employed in these works. Today we consider these works examples of Fine Art of the period. The dictionary definition of art is met. The same could be said for Greek art from the early period through the Classical period, or of Roman art, or of Byzantine art, and so on up into current time.

            The Dadists and Surrealists added a twist in the early part of the 20th century by stating that art is whatever the artist says is art. Thus, we get a urinal being proclaimed art followed by ripples in all directions that in some cases remove the artist from the center of the creative process. Art becomes an idea, a concept, an ephemeral expression, or art becomes a machined, mass-produced object that is given the stamp of the artist and sent out into the world. Art can still be found in galleries and museums, but it is also on shelves in Wal-Mart, K-Mart, and other discount venues.

            It is my belief that the artist decides for him or herself what is appropriate, and what is art. Not everyone will agree on the definition, its parameters, or its applications. This might easily contribute to a muddled mess, but in some ways it democratizes the experience and its availability. Whether this is a good thing is yet to be determined.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post