Blog
A Touchy Subject
Posted on 9/17/2012
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

The Death of Socrates
An article in the September issue of Wired Magazine looks briefly at the disgust factor that generally protects us from ingesting things that could be harmful. Parents, of course, have to be diligent around small children who usually have not developed aversion to many things. They often use taste as a way to explore their world. In the not too distant future, however, we will have challenges with food and water shortages on a vast scale. Some countries already suffer from these challenges, areas of drought not being the least of these. Singapore is recycling sewage through sophisticated processing to produce nearly thirty percent of its potable water. It is also suggested in the article that we may, as some cultures do already, start eating insects as potential replacement for meat, the production of which is highly energy inefficient and resource wasteful. To the West, in particular, becoming bug eaters could be a significant challenge even though some insects are highly nutritious.
Culturally, we learn many ideas that in cultures different from our own would seem strange or perhaps disgusting. The reverse is also true; some practices in other cultures might offend us. Even within a single culture, there are sub-groups that for traditional, religious, or other reasons have beliefs that may put them at odds with the larger culture. Humans have proved to be fairly adaptable through many generations, but humans can also be very rigid and strongly opposed to change. So many of the ideas that we accept as being right or true or “the way it is” are only ideas among a shared group. As soon as we reach out to a larger audience, we must make adjustments so as not to offend or alienate others that may not share our views. Business people are challenged with this every day in international business. We also see the results of spiritual conflicts where misunderstanding and misinterpretation come from insensitivity, or in some cases, intolerance for another’s beliefs.
Historically, art has illustrated some of these conflicts in varieties of ways. In ancient times there were many depictions of one group subjugating another, of practitioners of a set of beliefs being punished for those beliefs, or of a system of beliefs being raised above others to the level of governance and required obeisance. We also see practices that might be anathema to one group being praised in the art of another. For example, there are many cases of eroticism in art that are rarely, if ever, discussed or portrayed in art history literature. Ancient Greece, Rome, India, South America, Native America, China, Japan, and other Asian cultures all contain examples of eroticism that were normal to the time and culture. Christianity and Islam, however, generally took exception to these kinds of expressions, either labeling them sinful or heretical or antithetical to their doctrine. America still struggles to clearly define what is permissible and what is not with respect to publishing, public display, or distribution of erotic material.
Many today find challenges in certain characters or themes in television shows – excessive violence, nudity, sex, homosexuality, terrorism, religious irreverence – we could make a lengthy list. I use television as an example since this is probably the common denominator of cultural expression. We could just as easily apply this to visual art, music, theater, or dance. Fine art is not the common denominator although the community standard (to determine pornography) is applied in the arts as elsewhere. Personally, I’m not interested in community standards. A lot of idiocy passes that test too easily. Neither am I offended by much in the arts whether in the form of satire, irreverence, or outrage. I, and I suspect many artists as well, have developed my own critical system by which I judge whether to view or not to view anything artistic, cultural, religious, whatever. I definitely do not want others making judgments for me even though much is pre-judged before I even get to consider it. Such is the way of culture.
Leave a Comment