Blog
Image or Idea
Posted on 9/23/2012 6:07:00 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Teaching Art | Thoughts on Art

Breughel's Icarus
There are many ways to think about art and to think about painting. The most successful art and/or painting probably works on several levels of meaning at once. In fact, most artists would insist on that. There are some works, though, that could largely be considered either as paintings of images or paintings of ideas. Some artists may be better known as painters of images or painters of ideas. Whichever direction an artist goes, the painting itself, the technique and execution, should fit the image or the idea.
Looking back into art history, I’d say that much painting for several hundred years is painting of ideas. The images are important, to be sure, but the ideas are what make the paintings what they are. Since most paintings up to the late nineteenth or early twentieth centuries are realistic, we could say that the paintings are illustrations of certain ideas. Most religious paintings, for example, illustrate the annunciation, the nativity, the crucifixion, the resurrection, and other episodes from the Bible. Artists interpreted these scenes in quite different ways, sometimes infusing emotional power as in the crucifixions by Matthias Grunewald. Rembrandt’s The Blinding of Samson is a particularly emotionally powerful representation that conveys Samson’s agony through his clenched fists and curled toes as one eye is brutally gouged. The scene is dramatically lighted with deep light-dark contrast and angular shapes. It is a very strong example of how idea and image can fully support each other, but the narrative idea is still paramount.
Paintings that referenced Greek or Roman mythology also basically illustrated scenes from well-known tales and legends. From the Renaissance forward, painters expressed their ideas through these accepted forms of religious and secular subjects. Images became more sophisticated, realistic, interpretive, either intellectually cool (like the neo-classicists) or fervently emotional (the romantics), but in my opinion it was landscape where painters explored image more than idea. Other than representation of place, the idea could take a back seat to the image. Space, color, light, and texture could shine forth without the distraction of a particular narrative or cast of characters getting in the way. Moving into the twentieth century, though, increasing numbers of painters became interested in ideas about art that underlie a painting.
Perhaps because the academies were so successful in defining the rules of painting, images were fairly tightly controlled for generations. Many artists began to question basic assumptions about art, and paintings became expressive of particular ideas to illustrate the artists’ thinking. Classical and religious narrative images in painting were excised. Immediate surroundings were initially explored, so the character of the image shifted to the ordinary and everyday experience. For many painters, even those observations were distracting from what they felt was more fundamental to painting – colored shapes on a surface. The concept of pure painting, which was never really pure from the outset, gave way to the idea of making art as fundamentally personal expression. Painting represented only itself, but what seemed to happen is that painting began to represent the individual ideas of the artists. Abstraction, flatness, expression, process, non-objective were the new buzz-words, and an anything goes attitude became broadly popular. Artists again became painters of ideas but ideas that were self-generated.
Obviously during this shift into so-called modern painting, there were many who continued to explore traditional means although not so much under the auspices of an academy. Some maintained those ties. Thus, today we have art that moves a hundred directions at once. Many find this exciting and others find it disconcerting. Still, it can be interesting to consider a painting from the standpoint of its imagery or its ideas or how skillfully the artist may blend the two together. The possibilities are certainly richly varied.
Leave a Comment