Blog
Size and Scale
Posted on 9/28/2012 7:25:52 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Rembrandt Drawing
Size and scale are interrelated concepts that at certain periods of art history have had enormous impact. Anyone approaching art history for the first time may do so through a survey course or some basic art text like H. W. Janson’s History of Art. Janson’s book has been revised several times since I first used it in an art history course in the mid-sixties. I particularly remember a photograph of the Venus of Willendorf, the prehistoric sculpture of a woman with exaggerated hips and breasts, usually referred to as a fertility figure. No kind of written record of this artifact – or numerous others like it that emerged from various parts of prehistoric Europe – exists, so historians and archaeologists have essentially guessed about its importance and use in the culture of the time.
In reproduction, the scale of the piece is difficult to determine. It could possibly be nearly life size. Surprisingly, it is less than six inches high, and more recent speculation is that it and its sister versions were portable art forms for semi-nomadic people. The sculpture is quite remarkable for its blend of realism and abstraction. It is not a portrait since facial features have been ignored. It generalizes much of the form, and yet it has a kind of personality or expressiveness that differentiates it from other similar sculptures. In reproduction, though, size and scale are difficult to appreciate.
When I first studied art history, many images were shown in book illustrations or projected as slides on a classroom or lecture hall screen. Students might see the Sphinx or Egyptian pyramids on the same size as a Vermeer portrait like The Girl with a Pearl Earring. Sometimes photographs of monumental works might include people or animals that would help the viewer comprehend the scale of the illustrated piece. However, learning from reproductions one could develop a very distorted understanding of many art images from quite different time periods.
I distinctly remember my first view of an actual Vermeer painting in the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. The experience was quite surreal. I had been expecting a life-size portrait, but what I saw was a relatively small painting much reduced from normal human size. The exhibition room was darkened and the painting illuminated by spotlights, which further removed it from its surroundings. The painting literally became a window into a new reality. The importance of size and scale was dramatically impressed upon me.
Later that same day, I saw a monumental Barnett Newman painting that I only knew from reproduction. The illustration was about eight by six inches in size. The actual painting was larger than eight by six feet. That tiny image made no sense in relation to the actual work even though the proportions were the same and the colors were fairly accurate. Scale, however, created an entirely different experience for me.
Today, we have become used to experiencing television images, computer images, and virtual reality. Scale is continually being reduced with the introduction of I-pods and I-phones. The images may be clear and sharp, but just as with older slide technology, paintings and artwork generally are greatly distorted by the imposed uniformity and the lack of physical texture, depth, and dimension. I’m not a psychologist, but I can’t help but think that these perceptual alterations are affecting our experience and our interaction with art and the world around us in unpredictable ways. How these changes might manifest may not be known for some time to come.
Leave a Comment