Blog
Imaginary Review
Posted on 10/10/2012
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Learning about Art | Thoughts on Art

Desert Clouds
Artist A paints in oils mostly and creates images of the town and surroundings where she lives. Many of the scenes she depicts show ordinary people engaged in everyday activities: shopping, walking the dog, eating and chatting in a restaurant or coffee shop, working in the garden, and so on. These might be called genre scenes, but there is nothing revelatory or psychologically probing or even narrative other than the brief snapshot of a few moments of life in a small community. The style is straightforward with no particular emphasis on texture, brushwork, or use of color. In short, the paintings are illustrational, but there is consistency in style and lighting and unobtrusive point of view.
Artist B also paints in oils, but his work focuses predominantly on landscape. He utilizes more paint and creates texture with both brush and knife in a semi-impressionistic style. The color is clean and bright rather than atmospheric and moody. He tends to avoid the obvious drama of sunrise or sunset but creates dynamic tension with the light and shadow contrasts. The somewhat impressionistic use of broken color avoids muddiness and infuses the paintings with a sense of natural light. Though images depict actual places, the artist is not concerned with photographic representation; neither does he arbitrarily alter scenes solely for emotional effect. Remaining true to the initial idea is more important than spontaneous effects or unexpected results, and the looseness in paint handling belies the careful planning of each composition.
Artist C has wide-ranging interests and produces work that covers a lot of stylistic ground. Some of his paintings are based on personally taken photographs used to study low light settings, people focused on work tasks from construction to office work, landscape settings with pronounced light-dark contrasts, or worn, aged, or weathered objects chosen for their textures. All of these are interpreted in realistic or semi-abstract styles. He also does collage work that combines elements from his own life and experience with drawings or oil sketches and sometimes portions of his photographs. Another area of interest focuses on the influence of color on images. Here he makes paintings where half the image is painted in color and the other half is painted in black and white. The juxtaposition illustrates contrast but also relates to the artificiality of the reality that art, especially representational art, produces.
Each artist is steeped in his or her work and is dedicated to developing and refining its quality over time. Critics and/or viewers will approach each artist’s work according to their own preconceived notions concerning art, beauty, personal expression, and level of understanding. This is normal and natural, and the educated viewer, whether critic or layperson, will likely ask questions regarding the body of work viewed. Artists A and B may fare well as long as there is consistency in quality and style and the viewer doesn’t come up against something that is personally distasteful. Artist C, on the other hand, may be at greater risk for criticism because of the varied nature of the work. Also, because some of the work may be more challenging for the viewer – it requires understanding of both underlying concept and the image for its impact – some viewers may be put off by this extra effort. Additionally, the different stylistic expressions may invite unfavorable comparison of one with another. A more traditional example of work may be judged one way while the less traditional may be deemed not as good especially if the latter doesn’t demand a comparable level of craftsmanship in its realization. This can certainly happen in a group show among disparate artists. With mixed work by a single artist, the viewer may exhibit less patience. If this guy can make paintings like these, one might ask, why waste time on something more conceptual and crude?
There are many artists, however, who have explored a variety of styles and types of work in their careers. Picasso immediately comes to mind as does Miro. Quite a few so-called modern artists experimented with different forms and styles in their search for new ways of seeing and conceiving. The traditional approaches of the past held less attraction for them. The resultant work was and is often challenging to viewers. There also, particularly with sculpture and fine crafts, is a lot of art with a very contemporary look that was created by traditional methods. This blend of traditional and modern may sometimes be challenging, but it is also exciting and provocative. Art today is richer in variety than ever before.
Leave a Comment