Blog
Flights of Fancy
Posted on 11/2/2012
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

As a long time student of film, my appreciation for this art form extends over a wide range of styles and individual filmmakers. My tastes in literature and painting are equally catholic. With painting, I feel totally at home with representational and abstract styles. My own painting currently is pretty solidly in a representational vein, but there have been extended periods where I explored abstraction and expressionism. I am not of the belief that there is one style to which any particular artist should adhere. Some may choose to follow a certain path, and that is their freedom to do so. Filmmakers can explore themes from varieties of perspectives from film to film with sometimes widely divergent stories.
One filmmaker that I have enjoyed following for years is Woody Allen. Unlike the blockbuster moviemakers who seem to enjoy big bangs for big bucks, Allen is the quieter type willing to explore the nuances of human character and relationships mostly with a dose of wry humor. He is not averse to utilizing fantasy, again a quiet variety instead of mythical kingdoms and exotic locales. It is the fantasy of daydreams and wishes rather than that of nightmares and goblins. He also frequently utilizes an alter-ego who is generally a writer, scriptwriter, or struggling novelist. Many of his films are outright comedies that include a lot of slapstick like Sleeper or Love and Death. Others explore individual relationships that sometimes closely mirror Allen’s own life dilemmas: Annie Hall, Hannah and Her Sisters, Manhattan, or Husbands and Wives.
My two favorites are also some of his most imaginative – The Purple Rose of Cairo and Midnight in Paris. Both contrast fantasy and reality in wonderfully humorous ways. They also explore, as do many of his films, the relationship between art, artifice, and life. Each spills into the other in richly entertaining ways. I know for myself, and I think this is true for many who are drawn to the arts, the struggle of the artist to come to terms with the artistic reality is as challenging as how we construct our everyday reality. With art one always has the opportunity to do over something that is not working. The form gets set, but there still exists the option for change. Life does not always afford the chance to redo something that has not worked. Also in art the characters are the ones that work through problems and challenges, so there is distance between artist and character as well as between audience and character.
Some may consider Midnight in Paris rather light entertainment, but Allen addresses a number of artistic issues that are also very real human issues for many people. Two lines in particular that stood out to me are, first, “the past has always had a great charisma for me.” He illustrates this with several characters. The modern day alter-ego fantasizes about Paris of the 20s and magically visits there where he encounters some of his heroes like Hemingway, Gertrude Stein, and Scott Fitzgerald. A 20s Parisian flapper he also meets fantasizes about the Belle Epoch of Toulouse-Lautrec, Degas, and Gauguin, and when she and the alter-ego manage to visit there, she chooses to remain in that past. The Gauguin character fantasizes about the Renaissance as the greatest period in history. The alter-ego comes to realize that one has to choose to fully be in the present.
The second line has to do with art not being sufficient to fully express the life and soul of a great city. The city is a metaphor for the unrealized dream, and by implication art cannot express that either although the film is doing so beautifully as the audience can see but the main character has yet to realize. Again the alter-ego, Pender, says in speaking about Paris, “every street, every boulevard is its own special art form.” The film begins with a dozen or more still shots of different street scenes, which immediately prepares the audience for the filmmaker’s special look at this special city that has attracted artists for many generations. It is not until over halfway into the film that Pender makes this observation to the young flapper he has fallen in love with. By this time, we as audience have been fully captured by the magic of the filmmaker’s art. We know that art can capture the essence of many things including the vicissitudes of life. That we can experience this in a humorous, witty, imaginative, and fun way is one of the gifts that Woody Allen as artist so often bestows.
Leave a Comment