Blog
Experiments
Posted on 11/4/2012 7:00:20 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art History | Making Paintings | Thoughts on Art

Scientists use experimentation as a basis for the advancement of knowledge. Something is not considered truly knowable unless it can be experimentally verified. Experiments must be designed carefully so that variables are kept to a minimum and results can be accurately repeated from one experiment to the next. If another scientist or team of scientists cannot repeat an experiment and create the same results as the initial experiment, then the results of the first are called into question. Verification is fundamental. Part of the irony of advanced science today is that much experimentation is done in a kind of virtual reality; it is solved with mathematics rather than the traditional method of observation.
Experimentation in the arts is quite a different matter. Artists often use trial and error as the means for experimenting with new techniques or new approaches to subject matter or pushing in a new stylistic direction. As with most outcomes in the arts, the success or failure of experimentation is subjective rather than scientifically objective. Painters may rework paintings after some lapse of time and take them in entirely new directions. Work that may have been set aside without completion can also be reworked to surprising new results. Those results, however, may not always be satisfactory. Even paintings following a successful stylistic expression are not guaranteed success. Every painter knows this; consequently, painters often heavily edit their work. Some paintings never make it to exhibition, experimental or not.
Looking through art history, we can find many examples of artists’ experimentation as they move towards new styles. Quite a few of these examples seem like logical progressions as we look in hindsight. Jackson Pollock’s radical departures from regional realism into abstract surrealism and then expressionistic abstraction that culminates in his breakthrough drip paintings is one remarkable journey that appeared to pay off for a time. Some critics have said that he took himself down a blind alley. There was nowhere else for him to go. We’ll never know since he died before accomplishing more. The young Van Gogh painted many traditional landscapes before his seminal painting of the potato eaters. This was a new stylistic direction for him that soon evolved into more colorful, heavily pigmented paintings that he is known for today. He, too, may have burned himself out, and some critics view the crows in a field as symbolic foretelling of his imminent death.
Not every artist is as tortured as Pollock or Van Gogh, and experimentation doesn’t always end in suicide. Piet Mondrian, like many modern masters, began painting representational subjects. His series of tree paintings that become increasingly abstract over a progression of roughly six paintings was a deliberate experiment with altering an observable image to create something new. When he made the leap into geometric abstraction, there was no looking back. Again in hindsight, we can read the experimental paintings as harbingers of coming abstraction, but those early experiments in abstracted realism do not foretell the rigid geometry of Mondrian’s mature painting style. There are no intermediate steps. As with most anything new, there is always the possibility that some experiments may well be dead ends. Each artist has to make the final decision. All art is risky business.
Leave a Comment