Blog
Political Moodswings
Posted on 11/6/2012
By Donald Fox
2 Comments
Topics: Art and Culture | Art History | Thoughts on Art

Inspiration Point
Browsing in the school library today – no, I mean actually browsing the shelves and not the internet – I came across a book published in 1992, exactly 20 years ago, entitled Culture Wars: Documents from the Recent Controversies in the Arts. The book is centered around controversies over continued funding of the National Endowment for the Arts in the U.S. Senate at that time. Various players are some of my favorite characters from this period including my least favorite senator from North Carolina, Jesse Helms. I could say a lot of critical things about him just as I could for some senators from Texas, but that would be beside the point. Not only are art and politics strange bedfellows, but also both are equally controversial for similar and divergent reasons.
This time period involves some of the most offensive (to some) and unusual art expressions that trump even Duchamp and the Dadaists. Talk about surreal in the extreme. Andres Serrano’s Piss Christ and Robert Maplethorpe’s homoerotic photographs had both been funded with grants from the NEA. Both led to widespread criticism, closing of exhibitions, demonstrations, censorship, and continuing reverberations within the political and art communities that continue to this day – and may continue for some time into the future. These events also prominently displayed the deep divide between some extreme left wing and extreme right wing components of both the artistic and political communities.
Artistic controversies, in particular controversies over eroticism and pornography, have been around since ancient times. We can find evidence of such in both ancient Greece and Rome. Some cultures embraced eroticism while others tried to control it. Some praised its spiritual dimension and others pronounced it vulgar and sinful. The nineteen eighties in America were not the first time that legislators attempted to define pornography or to denounce both the makers and supporters and even those that tolerated such expression.
In democratic societies there seems to be an ever shifting line between what is allowed and what is not, what is tolerated and what is suppressed, what is honored and what is banned. Agreement itself is a somewhat elusive idea that becomes as much a political football as anything. We can agree on this issue if later we can agree on another issue. I’ll give ground here if you’ll give ground later on. This seems civilized enough until one side decides that there is no compromise, for even to compromise a little now for later gain means that one’s entire system of belief is called into question. If I truly believe something, how can I compromise even a little bit? This, unfortunately, is the state of much in politics and the arts today. The tolerance level is at an all-time low. Generosity of spirit seems to have disappeared. Interest in culture and ideas other than one’s own is only allowable for the option of converting the other to the true way of being. This has always been the challenge of religion, and religion has now spilled into everything. No longer is it just about me and my relation to my God. It has to be my God for everyone without exception. This, however, is not democracy nor is it truly religious – it is simply demagoguery and dogmatism.
In spite of everything, I still feel relatively hopeful on this Election Day. The controversies will likely continue in some form or other. The political pendulum will continue to swing, but I’m trusting that civility will make a comeback and that the naysayers will tire of their sniping and backbiting. Perhaps we’ll learn to take our elevated position within the animal kingdom with a bit more responsibility and exercise the one trait that does separate us from other animals – restraint.
2 Responses to Political Moodswings
Leave a Comment