Blog
Synchronicity
Posted on 11/11/2012 4:44:53 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

Art and Artifice
I was reminded again recently about Woody Allen’s Midnight in Paris when I happened to see Luis Buñuel’s The Exterminating Angel. In Allen’s film, the protagonist, a hack Hollywood screenwriter who is in Paris with is fiancée and future in-laws, either fantasizes or is magically drawn back to 1920s Paris where he meets a variety of artists and writers including Buñuel. On one scene, the writer, Pender, encounters Buñuel again while leaving a party and off-handedly mentions a “great idea” for a film: guests at a fancy dinner party find themselves trapped and unable to leave the room even though nothing appears to hold them there. Buñuel is perplexed and keeps asking, “Why don’t they just leave?” It’s an inside joke for film buffs.
The Exterminating Angel was a very serious film, controversial when it came out in the early 60s, and has become something of a cult classic. The story was quite unusual for its time, but the surrealist twist is not quite so strange when viewers realize that the story is a modern day fairytale. Whatever spell has been cast over the dinner guests is ultimately broken after a nightmarish journey through depravity, death, and a kind of redemption.
Art often requires suspension of disbelief in order to achieve its ends. This is most obvious in theater, but it also applies to literature, music, and painting. In film, there are crew members whose job is to maintain consistency within scenes and within the final cut of the film. Inconsistencies break the flow of the story and pull the viewer out of the aesthetic experience. Sometimes cut scenes, the outtakes, may be shown at the end of a film during or after credits to amuse the audience.
Ten or fifteen minutes into the story of The Exterminating Angel, however, there is a serious error that some viewers may not even notice. The lady of the house, upset over several serving errors by her staff, comes into the kitchen to find that the chef and his assistant are leaving. They explain that all the food is prepared and a sick relative requires attention. As the madam berates them, a boom microphone extends into the lower portion of the picture frame. If one is focused on the characters’ interactions, the gaffer’s gaff might not be noticed. An observant viewer, however, will be distracted, amused, and instantly pulled out of the developing story. The artistic illusion has been shattered. The scene should have been re-shot, or at least edited to maintain continuity.
In theater, actors learn how to deal with distractions and mistakes: doors that stick or don’t properly close, props that are missing or don’t work, missed cues, or fumbled lines. These are part of the challenge of live theater. Writers usually have editors that may make suggested changes to fix inconsistencies or to strengthen passages. Painters have to be their own editors, and all artists will be subject to critics’ reviews or audiences’ responses.
There is great value in the aesthetic experience. We can learn about life, the experiences and challenges of others, and about ourselves. We can derive pleasure from something well crafted. We can learn from artistic fictions about real situations without having to directly experience those situations. The stronger the believability the artist’s statement is the more powerful the experience for the audience. It is in the interest of both artist and audience that the artist should take great care in crafting the artwork so that the aesthetic experience will be as powerful and profound as possible.
Leave a Comment